First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) judgments from 2024

200 judgments from the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) in 2024, page 5 of 12.

Elmleigh Court, Petersfield Road, Midhurst, West Sussex, GU29 9HBCHI/45UD/LSC/2023/0170 · 2024
43 Somerstown, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 6ALCHI/45UD/MNR/2024/0002 · 2024
Cranlegh Cottage, Knightons Lane, Dunfold, Godalming, GU8 4NUCHI/45UD/OAF/2024/0002 · 2024
14 Lewisham Close Crawley West Sussex RH11 9LUCHI/45UE/F77/2023/0080 · 2024
3 St George’s Court, Northgate, Crawley, RH10 8LPCHI/45UE/HMC/2024/0004 · 2024
34 Priors Walk, Crawley, West Sussex RH10 1NYCHI/45UE/HNA/2024/0007 · 2024
4 Cross Path, Crawley, West Sussex RH10 8BWCHI/45UE/HNA/2024/0008 · 2024
2 Arun Cottages, Loxwood, Billingshurst, West Sussex RH14 0RECHI/45UF/F77/2024/0002 · 2024
Stable Cottage, Woodmans Farm, Ashington, Pulborough, West Sussex, RH20 3AUCHI/45UF/MNR/2024/0117 · 2024
Star Cottage Brighton Road Newtimber Hassocks West Sussex BN6 9BHCHI/45UG/F77/2024/0027 · 2024
21A Brunswick Road, Shoreham-by-Sea, West Sussex, BN43 5WACHI/45UG/MNR/2023/0299 · 2024
Flat 32 Ribbetts House Trinity Road Hurstpierpoint Hassocks West Sussex BN6 9XECHI/45UG/MNR/2024/0086 · 2024
Bolney Stage Cottage, London Road, Bolney, Haywards Heath, West Sussex RH17 5RLCHI/45UG/MNR/2024/0141 · 2024
86A South Road, Haywards Heath, West Sussex RH16 4LJCHI/45UG/MNR/2024/0176 · 2024
85 Chesterfield Road, Goring-By-Sea, Worthing, BN12 6BYCHI/45UH/HNA/2023/0031 · 2024
Flat 2, 4 Wallace Avenue, Worthing, West Sussex BN11 5RACHI/45UH/LBC/2023/0014 · 2024
Flats 23, 27a and 29 Tarring Road, Worthing, BN11 4EPCHI/45UH/LRM/2023/0006 · 2024
18 Rotary Lodge, 32 St Botolph’s Road, Worthing BN11 4JT : CHI/45UH/LSC/2024/0033 CHI/45UH/LSC/2024/0033 · 2024
Flat 11 Miller House 14-16 Farncombe Road Worthing West Sussex BN11 2FPCHI/45UH/MNR/2024/0130 · 2024
21 Broadwater Apartments, Southdownview Road, Worthing, West Sussex, BN14 8NNCHI/45UH/MNR/2024/0166 · 2024
Flat 3, 38 Grafton Road, Worthing, West Sussex, BN11 1QTCHI/45UH/MNR/2024/0171 · 2024
The Clock Inn Park, Lydeway, Wiltshire SN10 3PPCHI/46UB/PHI/2023/0548-0554 · 2024
36 Bungalow Park Bradenstoke Wiltshire SN15 4EPCHI/46UC/PHI/2023/0563 · 2024
46 & 69 Heath Farm, Heath Farm Caravan Park, Barford St Martin, Salisbury, Wiltshire, SP3 4BH: CHI/46UD/PHI/2023/0487 & 0488 CHI/46UD/PHI/2023/0487-AND-0488 · 2024
Flat 1, Gospel Hall, Langford Road, Bristol BS13 7ARCHI/OOHB/LSC/2023/0018 · 2024
55 Banner Road Bristol BS6 5NAHAV/00HB/F77/2024/0607 · 2024
44 Station Avenue, Bristol, BS16 2DUHAV/00HB/HMF/2025/0626 · 2024
364 Whitehall Road Bristol BS5 7BTHAV/00HB/MNR/2024/0504 · 2024
23 Stanton Road, Bristol, BS10 5SJHAV/00HB/MNR/2024/0511 · 2024
43 Providence Street Plymouth Devon PL4 8JQHAV/00HG/F77/2024/0501 · 2024
134 Mount Gould Road, Plymouth, Devon, PL4 7PYHAV/00HG/F77/2024/0610 · 2024
Evolution Cove, Durnford Street, Stonehouse, Plymouth, PL1 3EU : HAV/00HG/LDC/2024/0638 HAV/00HG/LDC/2024/0638 · 2024
Lytton House, St Lukes Road South, Torquay, Devon, Tq2 5PBHAV/00HH/LDC/2024/0513 · 2024
Flat 4 Stephanie Court 73 Poole Road Poole Dorset BH16 5HZHAV/00HP/MNR/2024/0510 · 2024
Flat 18, Barons Court, 100 Princess Road, Poole, BH12 1BPHAV/00HP/MNR/2024/0605 · 2024
The Pinnacle Flats 1 – 55, 57 St Peter’s Road, Bournemouth. BH1 2LHHAV/00HQ/LDC/2024/0612 · 2024
19 Hamilton Road, Bournemouth, BH1 4EQHAV/00HQ/LDC/2024/0613 · 2024
94 High Street, Corsham, Wiltshire, SN13 0HGHAV/00HY/F77/2024/0609 · 2024
Cottage Farm Bungalow Common Road Whiteparish Salisbury West Sussex SP5 2RFHAV/00HY/MNR/2024/0509 · 2024
2 Carver Cottages Barford lane Downton Salisbury Wiltshire SP5 3PXHAV/00HY/MNR/2024/0515 · 2024
Viceroy Lodge, Kingsway, Hove, East Sussex, BN3 4RAHAV/00ML/LDC/2024/0522 · 2024
Flat 2 16 Victoria Road Brighton BN1 3FSHAV/00ML/MNR/2024/0625 · 2024
Room 5, 69 Wadham Road, Portsmouth, Hampshire PO2 9EDHAV/00MR/MNR/2024/0614 · 2024
Flat 29 Mitchell Lodge, 50-56 West End Road, Southampton, SO18 6TGHAV/00MS/LBC/2024/0501 · 2024
Ocean Village Marina, Channel Way, Southampton, SO14 3QFHAV/00MS/LDC/2024/0517 · 2024
Flat 7 Elmlea Court 131-133 Lodge Road Southampton Hampshire SO14 6QTHAV/00MS/MNR/2024/0502 · 2024
2 Chestnut Crescent, Stoke Cannon, Exeter, Devon, EX5 4AAHAV/18UB/MNR/2024/0610 · 2024
117 St Katherines Road, Exeter, Devon EX4 7JJHAV/18UC/F77/2024/0604 · 2024
Flat 4-44 Powhay Mills, Tudor Street, Exeter, Devon, EX4 3BTHAV/18UC/LDC/2024/0621 · 2024
Church Cottage Bradstone Milton Abbot Devon PL19 0QSHAV/18UL/F77/2024/0606 · 2024
Longwood, 1 Fairfield Road, Eastbourne, East Sussex, BN20 7LTHAV/21UC/LDC/2024/0606 · 2024
Howard House,7-8 Howard Square Eastbourne, East Sussex,BN24 4BH: HAV/21UC/LDC/2024/0620 HAV/21UC/LDC/2024/0620 · 2024
42-54 Bodmin Close Eastbourne East Sussex BN20 8HZHAV/21UC/LDC/2024/0623 · 2024
Flat 2 Gowland Court, 137-139 Seaside Road, Eastbourne, East Sussex, BN21 3PGHAV/21UC/MNR/2024/0503 · 2024
Flat 3 Gowland Court, 137-139 Seaside Road, Eastbourne, East Sussex, BN21 3PGHAV/21UC/MNR/2024/0505 · 2024
Queens Apartments, Block B, 21-36 The Queens Apartments, Robertson Terrace, Hastings, East Sussex TN34 1LRHAV/21UD/LDC/2024/0506 · 2024
1 Mews Road, St Leonards On Sea, East Sussex, TN38 0EAHAV/21UD/LDC/2024/0523 · 2024
18a Downs Road Hastings East Sussex TN34 2DXHAV/21UD/MNR/2024/0617 · 2024
St James Heights, Paradise Walk, Bexhill On Sea, TN40 2LGHAV/21UG/LDC/2024/0520 · 2024
Shernfold Park, Frant, Tunbridge Wells, Kent, TN3 9DLHAV/21UH/LDC/2024/0611 · 2024
51 Down Ampney Cirencester Gloucestershire GL7 5QWHAV/23UC/F77/2024/0502 · 2024
52 Down Ampney Cirencester Gloucestershire GL7 5QWHAV/23UC/F77/2024/0507 · 2024
Various Properties of the Guinness Partnership LimitedHAV/23UE/LDC/2024/0509 · 2024
84 Dankworth Road, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG22 4LHHAV/24UB/F77/2024/0504 · 2024
7 Cherry Orchard Whitchurch Hampshire RG28 7HSHAV/24UB/MNR/2024/0624 · 2024
86 Denzil Avenue Netley Abbey Southampton Hampshire SO31 5BAHAV/24UD/F77/2024/0611 · 2024
Flats 1 – 12 Sea Pines, Victoria Road, Milford, Hampshire. SQ41HAV/24UJ/LDC/2024/0505 · 2024
5 St Catherines Road Winchester Hampshire SO23 0PPHAV/24UP/MNR/2024/0603 · 2024
Station House Station Road Charing Kent TN27 0JAHAV/29UB/F77/2024/0505 · 2024
101 Laurens Van Der Post Way, Ashford, Kent TN23 3GWHAV/29UB/MNR/2024/0517 · 2024
136 The Street Kingston Canterbury Kent CT4 6JQHAV/29UC/F77/2024/0503 · 2024
Regalpoint Court, 62A London Road, Maidstone, Kent, ME16 8QLHAV/29UH/LDC/2024/0625 · 2024
Flat 4D Arlington House All Saints Avenue Margate Kent CT9 1XPHAV/29UN/MNR/2024/0519 · 2024
24 Westbrook Road Margate Kent CT9 5AUHAV/29UN/MNR/2024/0612 · 2024
2 New Cottage Sherenden Road Tudeley Tonbridge Kent TN11 0PAHAV/29UQ/F77/2024/0614 · 2024
1 Crockhurst Farm Cottage Crockhurst Street Tudeley Tonbridge Kent TN11 0NTHAV/29UQ/F77/2024/0615 · 2024
Mount Ephraim Court, Molyneux Park Road, Tunbridge Wells, Kent, TN4 8DHHAV/29UQ/LDC/2024/0515 · 2024
Flat 3 Lavender Court, Molesham Way, West Molesey, Surrey, KT8 1NYHAV/43UB/MNR/2024/0501 · 2024
Flats 1-15 Greenbank Court, Sherwood Way, Epsom, Surrey KT19 8GYHAV/43UC/LDC/2024/0622 · 2024
167 Frimley Road, Camberley, Surrey, GU15 2PZHAV/43UJ/MNR/2024/0616 · 2024
6 Enfield Road, Crawley, RH11 9NAHAV/45UE/F77/2024/0603 · 2024
72 Northgate Road Crawley West Sussex RH10 1YAHAV/45UE/MNR/2024/0601 · 2024
Flat 44 Zurich House East Park Crawley West Sussex RH10 6GTHAV/45UE/MNR/2024/0621 · 2024
The Manor House, Causeway, Horsham RH12 1NQHAV/45UF/LDC/2024/0605 · 2024
32 Carnegie House Littlehampton Road Worthing West Sussex BN13 1NWHAV/45UH/MNR/2024/0518 · 2024
35 Durham Road, North Harrow, Middlesex, HA1 4PFHS/LON/00AQ/MNR/2024/0128 · 2024
each and every part of the adjoining and neighbouring property over which, as at the date of this Lease, rights have been granted to the Landlord for the benefit of the Property 127 Third Party Owner Clause 1.1 the owner(s) for the time being of the Third Party Property the owner(s) for the time being of the Third Party Property Agreed position Clause 1.1 Third Party Owner: the owner(s) for the time being of the Third Party Property 128 Cost of repair of the Access Clause 3.1.2 to pay to the Landlord within 28 days of demand a fair proportion according to user of the reasonable cost properly incurred and properly levied on the Landlord by the Third Party Property Owner pursuant to the terms of the relevant instrument as at the date of this Lease in the repair of the Access to pay to the Landlord within 28 days of demand a fair proportion according to user of the reasonable cost properly incurred and properly levied on the Landlord by the Third Party Property Owner pursuant to the terms of the relevant instrument as at the date of this Lease in the repair of the Access Agreed position 3.1.2 to pay to the Landlord within 28 days of demand a fair proportion according to user of the reasonable cost properly incurred and properly levied on the Landlord by the Third Party Property Owner pursuant to the terms of the relevant instrument as at the date of this Lease in the repair of the Access 129 Consent Clause 3.3.2 Where the Tenant is obliged to pay or indemnify the Landlord against any costs and expenses (whether under this or any other clause of this Lease) the Tenant shall only be liable for any costs and expenses in connection with obtaining any consent or approval from the Third Party Property Owner where that consent is required in accordance with the terms of the relevant transfer as at the date of this Lease Where the Tenant is obliged to pay or indemnify the Landlord against any costs and expenses (whether under this or any other clause of this Lease) the Tenant shall only be liable for any costs and expenses in connection with obtaining any consent or approval from the Third Party Property Owner where that consent is required in accordance with the terms of the relevant instrument as at the date of this Lease Agreed position 3.3.2 Where the Tenant is obliged to pay or indemnify the Landlord against any costs and expenses (whether under this or any other clause of this Lease) the Tenant shall only be liable for any costs and expenses in connection with obtaining any consent or approval from the Third Party Property Owner where that consent is required in accordance with the terms of the relevant instrument as at the date of this Lease 130 User Clause 3.4.2 not to permit or do any act or bring onto the Property anything which may constitute a nuisance or which may cause injury to the Landlord, Third Party Property Owner or other users in the vicinity of the Property or cause damage to the Third Party Property PROVIDED THAT the proper and lawful use of the Property and the exercise of the Rights in accordance with the terms of this Lease for and in connection with the Permitted Use shall not give rise to liability under this clause; 3.4.2.1 not to permit or do any act or bring onto the Property anything which may constitute a nuisance or which may cause injury to the Landlord and/or other users in the vicinity of the Property PROVIDED THAT the proper and lawful use of the Property and the exercise of the Rights in accordance with the terms of this Lease for and in connection with the Permitted Use shall not give rise to liability under this clause; 3.4.2.2 not to permit or do any act or bring onto the Property anything which may constitute a nuisance or which may cause injury to the Third Party Property Owner and/or cause damage to the Third Party Property; Clause 3.5.2 as set out in draft Lease. 131 Access 3.16.1 Subject always to the Tenant’s right to access the Property in accordance with Schedule 1 paragraph 1.1: 3.16.1.1 the parties shall act reasonably and in good faith to agree any reasonable and practical arrangements as are necessary to accommodate any reasonable requirement from time to time arising out of the Superior Landlord’s use of any adjoining land owned by the Superior Landlord. 3.16.1.2 when obtaining access to the Property the Tenant shall: (i) where applicable, re-lock any gates opened by the Tenant and their agents, employees and contractors and sharers in taking such access immediately after opening such gate; (ii) keep safe and secure any keys or key codes supplied to the Tenant by [the Superior Landlord or] the Landlord for the purpose of taking such access; and [(iii) comply with the reasonable security regulations from time to time issued by the Superior Landlord in respect of access to the Superior Landlord’s Premises PROVIDED THAT the Superior Landlord shall not make such regulations which may prevent preclude or adversely affect the exercise of the Rights by the Tenant and no charges shall be payable] (iv) comply with such arrangements as agreed pursuant to clause 3.16.1.1 Subject always to the Tenant’s right to access the Property in accordance with Schedule 1 paragraph 1.1: 3.16.1.1 the parties shall act reasonably and in good faith to agree any reasonable and practical arrangements as are necessary to accommodate any reasonable requirement from time to time taking into account the Third Party Owner’s requirements 3.16.1.2 when obtaining access to the Property the Tenant shall: (i) where applicable, re-lock any gates opened by the Tenant and their agents, employees and contractors in taking such access immediately after opening such gate; (ii) keep safe and secure any keys or key codes supplied to the Tenant by the Landlord for the purpose of taking such access; and (iii) comply with the reasonable security regulations from time to time issued by the Landlord in respect of access to the Property (iv) comply with such arrangements as agreed pursuant to clause 3.16.1.1 Mr Kitson conceded proviso at the hearing 132 Grant of Wayleaves Clause 4.2.1 If the Tenant requires, the Landlord will (upon payment of the Landlord’s reasonable and proper professional costs by the Tenant) grant such wayleaves to any statutory undertaker and/or public electricity supply authority for the installation of Conduits on over or under the Landlord’s Adjoining Property as may be necessary to enable the operation of the Installation for the Permitted Use and/or to enjoy the Rights, subject to and in accordance with clause 4.2.2 below If the Tenant requires, the Landlord will (upon payment of the Landlord’s reasonable and proper professional costs by the Tenant) grant such wayleaves to any statutory undertaker and/or public electricity supply authority for the installation of Conduits under such parts of the Property and/or the Landlord’s Adjoining Property shown edged blue on the Plan, as may be necessary to enable the operation of the Installation for the Permitted Use and/or to enjoy the Rights subject to and in accordance with clause 4.2.2 below OT wording as issue 12 133 Consent Clause 4.6 Subject to the Tenant paying to the Landlord, and where appropriate to the Third Party Property Owner, all solicitors and surveyors costs properly and reasonably incurred by the Landlord, and where appropriate by the Third Party Property Owner, in relation thereto the Landlord must use all reasonable endeavours to promptly obtain the consent and/or approval of the Third Party Property Owner, whenever the Tenant makes application for any consent and/or approval required under this Lease where the consent and/or approval of the Third Party Property Owner, is needed by virtue of the relevant transfer as at the date of this Lease. Subject to the Tenant paying to the Landlord, and where appropriate to the Third Party Property Owner, all solicitors and surveyors costs properly and reasonably incurred by the Landlord, and where appropriate by the Third Party Property Owner, in relation thereto the Landlord must use all reasonable endeavours to promptly obtain the consent and/or approval of the Third Party Property Owner, whenever the Tenant makes application for any consent and/or approval required under this Lease where the consent and/or approval of the Third Party Property Owner, is needed by virtue of the relevant instrument as at the date of this Lease. Agreed position 4.6 Subject to the Tenant paying to the Landlord, and where appropriate to the Third Party Property Owner, all solicitors and surveyors costs properly and reasonably incurred by the Landlord, and where appropriate by the Third Party Property Owner, in relation thereto the Landlord must use all reasonable endeavours to promptly obtain the consent and/or approval of the Third Party Property Owner, whenever the Tenant makes application for any consent and/or approval required under this Lease where the consent and/or approval of the Third Party Property Owner, is needed by virtue of the relevant instrument as at the date of this Lease. 134 Tenant’s right to access adjoining land for works Schedule 1 Pt 1 para 1.2 Subject to paragraph 1.1, the right upon giving to the Landlord not less than 48 hours’ prior written notice (except in the case of emergency or operational urgency when no notice shall be required) to enter and to remain upon the Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or Third Party Property other than buildings for only so long as is necessary for the purpose of carrying out any works to or on the Property and/or the Installation and/or the Access pursuant to the rights granted by this Lease the right upon giving to the Landlord not less than 48 hours’ prior written notice (except in the case of emergency or operational urgency when no notice shall be required) to enter and to remain upon such parts of the Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or Third Party Property shown edged blue on the Plan other than buildings for only so long as is necessary for the purpose of carrying out any works to or on the Property and/or the Installation and/or the Access pursuant to the rights granted by this Lease the right upon giving to the Landlord not less than 48 hours’ prior written notice (except in the case of emergency or operational urgency when no notice shall be required) to enter and to remain upon such parts of the Superior Landlord’s Adjoining Property/ Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or Third Party Property shown edged blue on the Plan other than buildings for only so long as is necessary for the purpose of carrying out any works to or on the Property and/or the Installation and/or the Access pursuant to the rights granted by this Lease 135 Tenant’s rights Schedule 1, Pt 1, Para 1.5 The right to lay in and upon the Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or Third Party Property or to grant to any public electricity supply authority and/or public electronic communications operator and/or statutory undertaker the right to lay in or upon the Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or Third Party Property in such locations and by such means and on such terms as shall first be approved by the Landlord in accordance with clause 4.2 (such approval not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed) such Conduits (including a separate power supply) to connect the Installation with any available electricity or electronic communications supply cable as the Tenant shall require for the purposes of the exercise of the Rights and thereafter use any such Conduits and such Conduits as exist at the date of this Lease for the Permitted Use and to inspect maintain adjust repair alter renew reroute and upgrade the same The right to grant to any public electricity supply authority and/or public electronic communications operator and/or statutory undertaker the right to lay in such parts of the Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or Third Party Property shown edged blue on the Plan in such locations and by such means as shall first be approved by the Landlord (such approval not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed)) such Conduits (including a separate power supply) and in accordance with clause 4.2 to connect the Installation with any available electricity or electronic communications supply cable as the Tenant shall require for the purposes of the exercise of the Rights and thereafter use any such Conduits and such Conduits as exist at the date of this Lease for the Permitted Use and to inspect maintain adjust repair alter renew reroute and upgrade the same. FTT wording Issue 22 136 Rights over Third Party Property Clause 4.7 New provision to be added to clause 4.7 as follows: 4.7.1 Where requested by the Tenant, and subject to the Tenant paying to the Landlord all solicitors and surveyors costs properly and reasonably incurred by the Landlord in relation thereto and subject to the Tenant indemnifying the Landlord against all losses, actions, claims, demands, compensation, damages, costs and expenses and increased costs and expenses relating to or arising from such action, to use reasonable endeavours to enforce the covenants on the part of the Third Party Property Owner contained in the relevant transfer.. Revised new provision to be added to clause 4.7 as follows: 4.7.1 Subject to the Tenant paying to the Landlord all solicitors and surveyors costs properly and reasonably incurred by the Landlord in relation thereto and subject to the Tenant indemnifying the Landlord against all losses, actions, claims, demands, compensation, damages, costs and expenses and increased costs and expenses relating to or arising from such action, to use reasonable endeavours to enforce the covenants on the part of the Third Party Property Owner contained in the relevant transfer. OT wording Revised provisions for leasehold sites where APW have the ability to grant rights over the Superior Landlord’s Property, being: - Carn Entral Farm / Camborne - Little Woodcote Lane / Carshalton - Hexton - Higher Hawksland - Ayot Green - Ampthill Manor Farm - Blackwell Grange - Moreton-in-Marsh NB: APW do not have the ability to grant rights over any Superior Landlord’s Property where there is no such property. 137 Grant of Wayleaves Clause 4.2.1 If the Tenant requires, the Landlord will (upon payment of the Landlord’s and Superior Landlord’s reasonable and proper professional costs by the Tenant) grant such wayleaves and/or use reasonable endeavours to procure that the Superior Landlord complies with its covenant under the Superior Lease (if applicable) to grant such wayleaves to any statutory undertaker and/or public electricity supply authority for the installation of Conduits on over or under the Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or the Superior Landlord’s Property as may be necessary to enable the operation of the Installation for the Permitted Use and/or to enjoy the Rights, subject to and in accordance with clause 4.2.2 below If the Tenant requires, the Landlord will (upon payment of the Landlord’s and Superior Landlord’s reasonable and proper professional costs by the Tenant) grant such wayleaves and/or use reasonable endeavours to procure that the Superior Landlord complies with its covenant under the Superior Lease (if applicable) to grant such wayleaves to any statutory undertaker and/or public electricity supply authority for the installation of Conduits under such parts of the Superior Landlord’s Property shown edged blue on the Plan as may be necessary to enable the operation of the Installation for the Permitted Use and/or to enjoy the Rights subject to and in accordance with clause 4.2.2 below OT wording [APW position misconceived. Wayleaves granted to statutory undertaker will be across adjoining land and not just limited to area edged blue. Statutory undertaker will need to run lines from existing positions across adjoining land] 138 Superior lease covenants Clause 4.7 New provision to be added to clause 4.7 as follows: 4.7.2 the Landlord shall use all reasonable endeavours to enforce the covenants on the part of the Superior Landlord contained in the Superior Lease during such period as the Superior Lease subsists Revised new provision to be added to clause 4.7 as follows: 4.7.2 Subject to the Tenant paying to the Landlord all solicitors and surveyors costs properly and reasonably incurred by the Landlord in relation thereto and subject to the Tenant indemnifying the Landlord against all losses, actions, claims, demands, compensation, damages, costs and expenses and increased costs and expenses relating to or arising from such action, the Landlord shall use reasonable endeavours to enforce the covenants on the part of the Superior Landlord contained in the Superior Lease during such period as the Superior Lease subsists 4.7.2 Where requested by the Tenant, and subject to the Tenant paying to the Landlord all solicitors and surveyors costs properly and reasonably incurred by the Landlord in relation thereto and subject to the Tenant indemnifying the Landlord against all losses, actions, claims, demands, compensation, damages, costs and expenses and increased costs and expenses relating to or arising from such action, the Landlord shall use reasonable endeavours to enforce the covenants on the part of the Superior Landlord contained in the Superior Lease during such period as the Superior Lease subsists New provision for leasehold and freehold sites where APW have the ability to grant such rights over the Superior Landlord’s Property or Third Party Property (as the case maybe), being: Leasehold sites: - Hexton - Higher Hawksland - Ayot Green - Ampthill Manor Farm - Blackwell Grange - Moreton-in-Marsh Freehold sites: - Sandbach - Hollow Farm (Chesterfield) - Newchurch NB: APW do not have the ability to grant rights for tree lopping over any Third Party Property at Ewefields Farm, Lubbards Lodge, Mildenhall (Bury St Edmunds) or. (Note: re Ewefields OTUK were party to 2024 Deed of Grant with third party land owner and if additional rights were required they should have obtained then). NB: APW do not have the ability to grant rights for tree lopping over any Superior Landlord’s Property at Carn Entral Farm (Camborne), Little Woodcote Lane (Carshalton). 139 Tree Lopping Schedule 1 Part 1 Paragraph 1.6 Additional provision to be added at Paragraph 1.6 of Part 1 of Schedule 1: The right to carry out any necessary pruning or trimming of trees or other plantings on the [Superior Landlord’s Property and/or Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or Third Party Property] if they interfere in any way with the effective operation of the Installation PROVIDED THAT all such works will first be approved by the [Landlord and/or Superior Landlord and/or Third Party Property Owner] as the case may be (such approval not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed. Option 1: No right No provision to be added for Ewefields Farm. Option 2: Right over Superior Landlord’s Property Additional provision to be added at Paragraph 1.6 of Part 1 of Schedule 1 at Hexton, Higher Hawksland, Ayot Green, Ampthill Manor Farm and Moreton-in-Marsh (where APW can grant rights over Superior Landlord’s Property): The right to carry out any necessary pruning or trimming of trees or other plantings on such parts of the Superior Landlord’s Property shown edged blue on the Plan if they interfere in any way with the effective operation of the Installation PROVIDED THAT all such works will first be approved by the Landlord and, in the case of the Superior Landlord, the relevant Superior Landlord as the case may be (such approval not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed by the Landlord). Option 3: Right over Third Party Property Additional provision to be added at Paragraph 1.6 of Part 1 of Schedule 1 at Sandbach, Hollow Farm (Chesterfield), Newchurch, Blackwell Grange, (where APW can grant rights over Third Party Property): The right to carry out any necessary pruning or trimming of trees or other plantings on such parts of the Landlord’s Adjoining Property and/or Third Party Property shown edged blue on the Plan if they interfere in any way with the effective operation of the Installation PROVIDED THAT all such works will first be approved by the Landlord and, in the case of the Third Party Property, the relevant Third Party Property Owner as the case may be (such approval not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed by the Landlord). The following additional words to be added to the end of paragraph 1.6 for Blackwell Grange, Ayot Green and Moreton-in-Marsh – “Further Provided That all cut timber and trimmings shall remain the Property of the Landlord or Third Party Property Owner (as appropriate) unless otherwise directed.” Option 4: Right over Landlord’s Adjoining Property Additional provision to be added at Paragraph 1.6 of Part 1 of Schedule 1 at Lubbards Lodge, Mildenhall (Bury St Edmunds), Carn Entral Farm (Camborne) and Little Woodcote Lane (Carshalton) and Ampthill Manor Farm, Hexton (where APW can only grant rights over any Landlord’s Adjoining Property that is owned by APW): The right to carry out any necessary pruning or trimming of trees or other plantings on such parts of the Landlord’s Adjoining Property shown edged blue on the Plan if they interfere in any way with the effective operation of the Installation PROVIDED THAT all such works will first be approved by the Landlord (such approval not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed by the Landlord). The right to carry out any necessary pruning or trimming of trees or other plantings that are either within the Landlord’s control or ownership or within the land shown edged blue on the Plan if they interfere in any way with the effective operation of the Installation PROVIDED THAT all such works will first be approved by the Landlord (such approval not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed). No provision for Ewefields New provision for leasehold and freehold sites where APW have the ability to grant such rights. 140 Rights over Third Party Property Paragraph 1.7 Part 1 Schedule 1 Additional provision to be added at Paragraph 1.7 of Part 1 of Schedule 1: [any other rights granted to the Landlord for the benefit of the Property as at the date of this Lease, subject to the same conditions imposed on the Landlord under the relevant instrument, and the Tenant will comply with any restrictions imposed on the Landlord in respect of those rights.] No provision to be included No provision to be included. [No business need has been established by OT to justify the grant of this wide ranging provision.] APPENDIX 3: New terms in disputeLC – 2023 – 000321 Schedule of Disputed Terms · 2024
LC – 2023 – 000322, 323, 332, 348 and 365 Lubbards Lodge (322) (Abbreviated Sandbach (348) Site Name) Blackwell Grange (365) Hexton (323) Ampthill (332)LC – 2023 – 000322, 323, 332, 348 and 365 Lubbards Lodge (322) (Abbreviated Sandbach (348) Site Name) Blackwell Grange (365) Hexton (323) Ampthill (332) · 2024
LC-2023-000410 Chilton Court Station Avenue Walton on Thames Surrey KT12 1NGLC-2023-000410 Chilton Court Station Avenue Walton on Thames Surrey KT12 1NG · 2024
LC – 2023 – 000548 Rooftop Site at Battle Bridge House, 300-306 Gray’s Inn Road WC1X 8DULC – 2023 – 000548 Rooftop Site at Battle Bridge House, 300-306 Gray’s Inn Road WC1X 8DU · 2024
LC – 2024 – 000030 Cliffe Farm, Swythamley SK11 OSWLC – 2024 – 000030 Cliffe Farm, Swythamley SK11 OSW · 2024
LC – 2024 – 000044 LC – 2023 - 000523 Vista Centre, 50 Salisbury Road, Hounslow TW4 6JQLC – 2024 – 000044 LC – 2023 - 000523 Vista Centre, 50 Salisbury Road, Hounslow TW4 6JQ · 2024
LC-2024-000071 Alder Castle 10 Noble Street London Ec2V 7JULC-2024-000071 Alder Castle 10 Noble Street London Ec2V 7JU · 2024
LC-2024-000071 Cost LC-2024-000071 Cost · 2024
LC – 2024-000537 Charles Burrell Centre, Staniforth Road, Thetford, Norfolk IP24 3LHLC – 2024-000537 Charles Burrell Centre, Staniforth Road, Thetford, Norfolk IP24 3LH · 2024
LC – 2024 – 00098LC – 2024 – 00098 · 2024
Telecommunications site at Ewefields Farm, Chesterton, Warwick CV33 9LQ and 13 others Claimant : On Tower UK LimitedLC – 2023 – 000321 and 13 others · 2024
Patricroft (852), Dalkeith (854), Compton Mills (856), Sandy Lodge (857) Hornsby (008) and Thackley FC (009) Claimant : On Tower UK Limited (1) On Tower UK 2 Limited (2)LC – 2023 – 000852, 854, 856 and 857 · 2024
Dial Stone Court, Oatlands Avenue, Weybridge, KT13 9DE registered under title number SY806350 Claimant : CORNERSTONE TELECOMMUNICATIONS (Operator) INFRASTRUCTURE LIMITED (CTIL)LC – 2023-000626 · 2024
Roof of multi-storey car park, St Marks Road, Mitcham, CR4 2JS registered under leasehold Title SGL625097 and freehold Title SGL460614. Claimant : CORNERSTONE TELECOMMUNICATIONS (Operator) INFRASTRUCTURE LIMITED (CTIL)LC-2023-000668 · 2024
Cornerstone Telecommunications Infrastructure Limited v VMMC Estates: LC-2023-000710LC-2023-000710 · 2024
135 and 135A, 137 and 137A Ravensbourne Gardens, Ilford, Essex IG50XGLON/00/00BC/LSC/2024/0175 · 2024
68 Stockwell Park Road, St John’s Park, London SW9 0DALON/00/0AY/HMF/2023/0200 · 2024
Endeavour House and Mayflower House, 47 Cuba Street London E14LON/00/BG/LSC/2023/0100 · 2024
49 Sir John Lyon House, 8 High Timber Street London EC4V 3PALON/00AA/LSC/2023/0126 · 2024
Flat 333, Lauderdale Tower, Barbican, London EC2Y 8NALON/00AA/LSC/2024/0018 · 2024
35 Harris Road, Dagenham, Essex RM9 5DT.LON/00AB/HIN/2023/0016 · 2024
205 Bonham Road, Dagenham, RM8 3BLLON/00AB/HMG/2024/0027 · 2024
30, Sterry Gardens, London, RM10 8PHLON/00AB/HNA/2023/0026-30-STERRY-GARDENS-LONDON-RM10-8PH · 2024
5 Warren Cottage, Whalebone Lane North, Romford RM6 6RBLON/00AB/HNA/2023/0086 · 2024
279 Sheppey Road RM9 4JU 16 Holden Close, Dagenham, Essex RM8 2QSLON/00AB/HTC/2024/0007 · 2024
59 Webbscroft Road, Romford, RM107NLLON/00AB/LSC/2023/0326 · 2024
50, 58, 62, 86, and 88 Trefgarne Road, Dagenham, RM10 7QSLON/00AB/LSC/2024/0045 · 2024
134 Ford Road, Dagenham, RM9 6LSLON/00AB/MNR/2023/0209 · 2024
17 Winterbourne Road, Dagenham, Essex, RM8 2JZ - LON/00AB/MNR/2024/0017 LON/00AB/MNR/2024/0017 · 2024
111 Galleons Drive, Barking, Essex, IG11 0FALON/00AB/MNR/2024/0038 · 2024
Flat 17 Eagle Lodge, Golders Green Road,, London, NW11 8BDLON/00AC/F77/2023/0380 · 2024
34A Golders Way, London, NW11 8JXLON/00AC/F77/2024/0021 · 2024
134A Ballards Lane, London N3 2PA.LON/00AC/F77/2024/0052 · 2024
1189A Finchley Road, London NW11 OAALON/00AC/F77/2024/0079 · 2024
65B Golders Green Road, London NW11 8ELLON/00AC/F77/2024/0108 · 2024
108A Golders Green Road, London NW11 8HBLON/00AC/F77/2024/0198 · 2024
19 Glenhill Close, London N3 2JSLON/00AC/F77/2024/0242 · 2024
56 The Drive, London, NW11 9TLLON/00AC/F77/2024/0253 · 2024
Flat 34 Heathway Court, Finchley Road, London, NW3 7TSLON/00AC/F77/2024/0273 · 2024
18 Pennine Drive, London NW2 1PBLON/00AC/HMF/2023/0278 · 2024
Suite 1, 31 Woodstock Road, London NW11 8ESLON/00AC/HTD/2024/0001 · 2024
27 Wendover Court, Finchley Road, London NW2 2PGLON/00AC/LDC/2023/0007 · 2024
Belview Lodge, 2B The Grove, London NW11 9SHLON/00AC/LDC/2023/0207 · 2024
Wendover Court, Finchley Road, London NW2 2PG and NW2 2PHLON/00AC/LDC/2023/0211 · 2024
Charlotte Court, 153-155 East Barnet Road London EN4 8QZLON/00AC/LDC/2023/0218 · 2024
Coachman’s Lodge, 24-26 Friern Park, Finchley, London N12 9DNLON/00AC/LDC/2023/0232 · 2024
Allingham Court, 44 The Bishops Avenue, London, N2 0BALON/00AC/LDC/2023/0301 · 2024
Mayflower Lodge, 10 Wetherill Road, London n10 2SHLON/00AC/LDC/2023/0302 · 2024
216-218a Sydney Road, Muswell Hill, London N10 2RSLON/00AC/LDC/2024/0007 · 2024
790 High Road, London, N12 9QRLON/00AC/LDC/2024/0041 · 2024
1-37 Aqua House, Agate Close, London, NW10 7FFLON/00AC/LDC/2024/0081 · 2024
Cliveden Court, 1 Lytton Road, London EN5 5BBLON/00AC/LDC/2024/0130 · 2024
Flat 8, 790 High Road, Finchley, London, N12 9QR: LON/00AC/LDC/2024/0136LON/00AC/LDC/2024/0136 · 2024
9 Henry Road, Barnet, EN4 8BLLON/00AC/LRM/2023/0026 · 2024
16 Sandringham Road London NW11 9DPLON/00AC/LSC/2023/0350 · 2024
Simmay Villas, 152 Holders Hill Road, London, NW7 1LULON/00AC/LSC/2023/0439 · 2024
Flat 15, 133 East Barnet Road, London EN4 8RFLON/00AC/MNR/2023/0349 · 2024
Flat 3 19 Brent Street London NW4 2EULON/00AC/MNR/2024/0015 · 2024
LON/00AC/MNR/2024/0018 - Flat 4 , 19 Brent Street, Hendon, London , NW4 2EULON/00AC/MNR/2024/0018-FLAT-4-19-BRENT-STREET-HENDON-LONDON-NW4-2EU · 2024
21 Glenhurst Road North Finchley London N12 9UBLON/00AC/MNR/2024/0029 · 2024
Flat 45 Ensign House, 48 Aerodrome Road, London, NW9 5ZRLON/00AC/MNR/2024/0362 · 2024
Flat 6, Buckingham Court, Watford Way, London NW4 4TDLON/00AC/OC9/2024/0038 · 2024
12 A Chalfont Court, Colindale Lane, Colindale, London, NW9 6 DYLON/00AC/OC9/2024/0072 · 2024
11 Oakley Drive London s.e.9 2HQLON/00AD/F77/2023/0405 · 2024
90 Burns Avenue, Sidcup, Kent. DA15 9HR.LON/00AD/F77/2024/0011-90-BURNS-AVENUE-SIDCUP-KENT-DA15-9HR · 2024
127 Sidcup Hill, Sidcup, Kent, DA14 6JSLON/00AD/F77/2024/0635 · 2024
Flats 1-8 Darlinghurst Court, Chatswood Mews, Carlton Road, Sidcup, DA14 6FBLON/00AD/LDC/2024/0019 · 2024
Milton Lodge, 6 Hadlow Road, Sidcup, DA14 4HULON/00AD/LDC/2024/0223 · 2024
Flat 1 Kings Court, 38 Hatherly Road, Sidcup, Kent DA14, 4ATLON/00AD/LSC/2021/0285 · 2024
102 Chandlers Drive, Erith, Kent, DA8 1LNLON/00AD/MNR/2024/0604 · 2024
8 Olive Road, London, NW2 6DBLON/00AE/F77/2023/0273 · 2024
17 Denzil Road, London NW10 2URLON/00AE/F77/2023/0298-17-DENZIL-ROAD-LONDON-NW10-2UR · 2024
1b Stanley Road, London NW2 4QH.LON/00AE/F77/2023/0307 · 2024
LON/00AE/F77/2023/0382 - 252A Willesden Lane, London, NW2 5RELON/00AE/F77/2023/0382-252A-WILLESDEN-LANE-LONDON-NW2-5RE · 2024
Flat A, 2 Minet Avenue, Harlesden, London NW10. 8AH.LON/00AE/F77/2024/0022 · 2024
3A Stanley Gardens Road , London,LON/00AE/F77/2024/0023 · 2024
79a St Raphaels Way London NW10 0NULON/00AE/F77/2024/0070 · 2024
23b Bramshill Road, London, NW10 8AELON/00AE/F77/2024/0159 · 2024
First Floor Flat, 171 Chevening Road, London NW6 6DTLON/00AE/F77/2024/0192 · 2024
17 Connaught Road, London, NW10 9AJLON/00AE/F77/2024/0206 · 2024
Flat 102 Bedford Gardens House, 13 Bedford Gardens, London, W8 7EELON/00AE/F77/2024/0230 · 2024
13 Exeter Mansions, Exeter Road, London NW2 3UGLON/00AE/F77/2024/0248 · 2024
Flat B, 15 Monson Road, London, NW10 5URLON/00AE/F77/2024/0262 · 2024
Flat A (First Floor Flat), 257 Kilburn Lane, London, W10 4BQLON/00AE/F77/2024/0274 · 2024
9a St. Pauls Avenue, London NW2 5SSLON/00AE/F77/2024/0664 · 2024
23 Elm Way, London NW10 0NGLON/00AE/HMF/2023/0269 · 2024
Flat 3, 76 Brondesbury Road, London, NW6 6RXLON/00AE/HMF/2023/0285 · 2024
60 London Road, Wembley, London, HA9 7HGLON/00AE/HMF/2024/0035 · 2024
169 Burnley Road, London, NW10 1EQLON/00AE/HML/2023/0040 · 2024
10 Uxendon Hill, Wembley HA9 9RULON/00AE/HNA/2023/0021 · 2024
66 Kingfisher Way, Brentfield Road, Neasden, London NW10 8TZLON/00AE/LAC/2021/0009 · 2024
Flats A, B & C, 171 Brondesbury Park, London NW2 5JN.LON/00AE/LDC/2023/0248 · 2024
The Coachworks, 9 Regent Street, Kensal Green, London NW10 5LGLON/00AE/LDC/2023/0255 · 2024
112 Brondesbury Villas, London, NW6 6AD LON/00AE/LDC/2023/0324LON/00AE/LDC/2023/0324 · 2024
Guinevere Court, King George Crescent, Wembley HA0 2FHLON/00AE/LDC/2024/0034 · 2024
23B Windsor Crescent, Wembley, HA9 9ANLON/00AE/LSC/2022/0141 · 2024
4a Brendon Avenue London NW10 1SSLON/00AE/LSC/2023/0225 · 2024
Chamberlayne Avenue, Wembley, HA9 8SRLON/00AE/LSC/2023/0269 · 2024
5A Allington Road, W10 4AYLON/00AE/LSC/2023/0424 · 2024
30 Drayton Waye, Kenton, Harrow, HA3 0BTLON/00AE/LSC/2024/0070 · 2024
24 and 24A Baker Road, London NW10 8UALON/00AE/LVT/2024/0004 · 2024
Flat 18 Farrans Court, Northwick Avenue, Kenton, HA3 0AT: LON/00AE/MNR/2023/0283LON/00AE/MNR/2023/0283 · 2024
Flat 23 Elstree Apartments, 72 Grove Park, London NW9 9FF - LON/00AE/MNR/2023/0480LON/00AE/MNR/2023/0480 · 2024
13A Pember Road, London NW10 5LRLON/00AE/MNR/2024/0184 · 2024
Flat A, 90 Clifford Gardens, London, NW10 5JBLON/00AE/MNR/2024/0207 · 2024
217 Church Road, London NW10 9EPLON/00AE/OAF/2024/0007 · 2024
50 Purves Road, London, NW10 5JELON/00AE/OCE/2023/0155 · 2024
47 Holmdale Road, Chislehurst, Kent, BR7 6BYLON/00AF/F77/2023/0219 · 2024
30 Bourne Road, Bromley, Kent, BR2 9NSLON/00AF/F77/2023/0325 · 2024
Flat 13 Graham Court, Cooden Close, Bromley, Kent, BR1 3TTLON/00AF/F77/2023/0391-FLAT-13-GRAHAM-COURT-COODEN-CLOSE-BROMLEY-KENT-BR1-3T · 2024
26 Otford Close London SE20 7WBLON/00AF/F77/2024/0149 · 2024
Flat 31, Burnt Ash Heights, Pike Close, Kent, BR1 5BS.LON/00AF/F77/2024/0167 · 2024
45A and 45B West Street, Bromley, BR1 1RE Appellant/applicant : J K West LimitedLON/00AF/HPO/2024/0006 · 2024
47 Manor Road, Beckenham, Kent, BR3 5JBLON/00AF/LCP/2023/0015 · 2024