Mr S Shields and others v Allma Construction Ltd (In Administration): 4106981/2023 and others
JUDGMENT
The Employment Judge has decided to issue the following judgment on the available material under rule 21.[1]The claimants are entitled to bring this claim because the complaint concerns a failure relating to the election of employee representatives, and the claimants were employees dismissed as redundant.[2]No response was presented to these claims within the applicable time limit.[3]The respondent is in administration but the administrator consented to the continuation of these proceedings in letters dated 12 September 2023, 10 October 2023, 24 October 2023, 30 October 2023, 31 October 2023 and 13 December 2023.[4]The complaints that the respondent failed to comply with a requirement of section 188 and section 188A of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 is well founded.[5]The respondent dismissed as redundant more than 20 employees at one establishment within a period of 90 days or less.[6]The respondent failed to ensure that employee representatives were elected in accordance with s.188A, and then to consult with them in accordance with s.188.[7]Under the terms of Rule 29 of the Employment Tribunal Rules of Procedure, the Tribunal Orders that these claims be considered together. 7. The Tribunal makes a protective award in respect of the claimants in the attached schedule, who worked at the respondent’s premises at 28 Muriel Street, Barrhead, Glasgow, G78 1QB and were dismissed as redundant and the respondent is ordered to pay remuneration for the protected period. The protected period begins with 17 August 2023 and is for 90 days. Employment Judge: S Maclean Date of Judgment : 09 April 2024 Multiple Schedule Multiple: 4100583 - ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED Case Number Case Name 4105316/2023 Mr James murphy -v- Allma Construction Limited (In Administration) 4105321/2023 Mr Terence McDermott -v- Allma construction (in administration) 4105504/2023 Mr Jack Anderson -v- Allma Construction Limited (In Administration) 4105505/2023 Mr John Brogan -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105506/2023 Mr Robert Brolly -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105507/2023 Mr David Callaghan -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105508/2023 Mr Garry Campbell -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105509/2023 Mr James Friel -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105511/2023 Mr Alex Graham -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105512/2023 Mr Robert Howie -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105513/2023 Mr Adam Kachach -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105514/2023 Mr Simon King -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105515/2023 Mr Ian King -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105516/2023 Mr Michael King -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105517/2023 Mr Colin Knowles -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105518/2023 Mr Stuart Lawrie -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105519/2023 Mr James Lennox -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105520/2023 Mr Darren Martin -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105521/2023 Mr Damion McAleer -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105522/2023 Mr Darren McBride -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105523/2023 Mr John McBride -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105524/2023 Mr Allan McGlinchey -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105525/2023 Mr Andrew McGowan -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105526/2023 Mr Anthony McIntyre -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105527/2023 Mr James McKinlay -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105528/2023 Mr Paul McManus -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105529/2023 Mr Graham McPhail -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105530/2023 Mr Jonathan Murray -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105531/2023 Mr Ronald Nailen -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105532/2023 Mr Darren Nailen -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105533/2023 Mr Paul Nailen -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105534/2023 Mr Ronnie Nailen -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105535/2023 Mr Mark Nailen -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105536/2023 Mr James Nicol -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105537/2023 Mr John Orr -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105538/2023 Mr Steven Potter -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105540/2023 Mr Mark Scally -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105541/2023 Mr Stuart Scott -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105542/2023 Mr Stuart Stirling -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105543/2023 Mr Alex Stirling -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105544/2023 Mr Connor Taylor -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105545/2023 Mr Graeme Thomson -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105546/2023 Mr Martyn Todd -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105547/2023 Mr David Webster -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105548/2023 Mr George Currie -v- Allma Construction Limited (In Administration) 4105549/2023 Mr Neil Higgins -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105550/2023 Mr Iain Hubbard -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105551/2023 Mr Andrew Mackie -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105552/2023 Mr Paul McGhee -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105553/2023 Mr Paul James McKeever -v- Allma Construction Limited 4105606/2023 David Stewart -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105607/2023 Mr Kevin Mille -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105608/2023 Mr RONNIE NORTON CRAIG -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105609/2023 Mr Darren Donachie -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105610/2023 Mr John Stirling -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105611/2023 Mr RONNIE CRAIG -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105612/2023 Ms Loraine Dougherty -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105613/2023 Mr Alexander Hyslop -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105614/2023 Mr Colin Johnstone -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105615/2023 Mr James Hail -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105616/2023 Mr Gary Duffy -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105617/2023 Mr Bernard Kangley -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105618/2023 Mr Christopher Swan -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105619/2023 Mr Ross Elder -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105620/2023 Ms Emily Reeve -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105621/2023 Mr Christopher Anderson -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105622/2023 Mr Neil McKenzie -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105623/2023 Mr Colin Thomson -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105624/2023 Mr Iain MacQueen -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105625/2023 Mr Kieran Moy -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105626/2023 Mr Brandon Rea -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105627/2023 Mr Joseph Ralph -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105628/2023 Mr Robert MacDonald -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105630/2023 Mr Gerard McClintock -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105631/2023 Mr Andrew Brown -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105632/2023 Mr Gary Gallagher -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105633/2023 Mr Rares-Valentin Tomescu -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105634/2023 Mr Barry Aitken -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105635/2023 Mr Stephen Andrew -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105636/2023 Mr Donald McMahon -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105637/2023 Mr Stuart Young -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105638/2023 Miss Melissa Walker -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105639/2023 Mr james McPartland -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105640/2023 Mr William Docherty -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105641/2023 Mr John Mullholland -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105642/2023 Mr Graeme Orr -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105643/2023 Mr Andrzej Oleszczuk -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105644/2023 Mr Donald Stewart Mackenzie -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105645/2023 Mr Ross Holland -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105646/2023 Mr Patrick McDonald -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105647/2023 Mr Stuart Cameron -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105648/2023 Mr John irvine -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105649/2023 Mr Gerald Rea -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105650/2023 Mr John James Barr -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105651/2023 Mr John Douglas Barr -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105652/2023 Mr Sean Donnell -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105653/2023 Mr Scott Adams -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105654/2023 Mr Keiran Moy -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105655/2023 Mr David Alcorn -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105656/2023 Mr Daniel Alcorn -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105658/2023 Mr David Sutherland -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105659/2023 Mr James Petrie -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105660/2023 Mr Andrew Brownlie -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105661/2023 Mr James Greene -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105662/2023 Mr Donald Edment -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105663/2023 Mr Gerald McGowan -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105665/2023 Mr Donald Cameron -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105666/2023 Mr Gary O'Kane -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105667/2023 Mrs Shirley Wilson -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105668/2023 Mr Damian P'Donnell -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105670/2023 Mr James Loudon -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105671/2023 Mr Michael McCarron -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105672/2023 Mr Michael McKeown -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105673/2023 Mr Robert McKelvie -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105675/2023 Mr William Ryan -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4105868/2023 Mr James Dunn -v- Allma Construction Limited (In Administration) 4105869/2023 Mr Kevin Donaghy -v- Allma Construction Ltd (In Administration) 4106981/2023 Stephen Shields -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED (In Administration) 4106982/2023 Mr Stephen Shields -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106983/2023 Mr Alistair Mackillop -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106984/2023 Mr Darren Doherty -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106985/2023 Mr Terrence Doherty -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106986/2023 Mr Neil Paterson -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106987/2023 Mr Tom Doyle -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106988/2023 Mr David McCluskey -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106989/2023 Mr Paul Carolan -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106990/2023 Mr Brian Robertson -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106991/2023 Mr Max McCluskey -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106992/2023 Mr David Hall -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106993/2023 Mr Christopher David Ireland -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106994/2023 Mr John Cannie -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106995/2023 Mr Cameron Dalgliesh -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106996/2023 Mr Ian Mulholland -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106997/2023 Mr John Coventry -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106998/2023 Mr Andrew McKillop -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED 4106999/2023 Mr William Gamble -v- ALLMA CONSTRUCTION LIMITED