Mr K M Quaid and 280 Others v IBM UK Ltd and IBM UK Holdings Ltd: 3100962/2010 and others

EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS

Case No 3100962/2010, 104029/2010, 104030/2010, 104041/2010, 104043/2010, 104130/2010, 104132/2010, 1200921/2010, 1304482/2010, 1304483/2010

Between

Mr K M Quaid and 280 OthersClaimant

IBM UK Ltd and IBM UK Holdings LtdRespondent

Before

Employment Judge Pirani

Date 13 January 2020

JUDGMENT

Confidential settlement terms having been agreed between the parties pursuant to which each of the 281 Claimants listed in the attached schedule have withdrawn their claims under these proceedings, the Tribunal orders that these proceedings are dismissed in respect of such Claimants. _____________________________ Regional Employment Judge Pirani Date: 6 November 2019 JUDGMENT SENT TO THE PARTIES ON 11 November 2019 FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE Case no: 3100962/2010 and 280 others Case no. Claimant

[1]3100962/2010 Mr KM Quaid

[2]104029/2010 Mr D Stewart

[3]104030/2010 Mr NE Paterson

[4]104041/2010 Mr WM Hamilton

[5]104043/2010 Dr D Little

[6]104130/2010 Mr E Foo

[7]104132/2010 Ms H Rumbold

[8]1200921/2010 Mr G Simmons

[9]1304482/2010 Mrs JR Lewis

[10]1304483/2010 Mr P Brook-Nolan

[11]1304484/2010 Mr AJ Palfreyman

[12]1400724/2010 Mr J Hicks

[13]1401201/2010 Mr G Ingram

[14]1401204/2010 Mr IJ Brown

[15]1401205/2010 Mr RO Rodd

[16]1803035/2010 Mr ML Guilford

[17]2317812/2010 Mr BK Blackhall

[18]2317813/2010 Mr WW Cheung

[19]2317815/2010 Mr R Fairhurst

[20]2317816/2010 Mr CT Gilbert

[21]2317818/2010 Mr R Moore

[22]2317819/2010 Mr SJ North

[23]2317820/2010 Mr P Wells

[24]2329766/2010 Ms MM Stragier

[25]2403131/2010 Mr JJ Burke

[26]2403132/2010 Mr ME Chapman

[27]2403133/2010 Mr SG Garratt

[28]2403135/2010 Mr JA Hanson

[29]2403137/2010 Ms ER Metcalfe

[30]2403138/2010 Mr NA Morton

[31]2403139/2010 Mr PD Earl

[32]2403140/2010 Mr JT Curtin

[33]2701212/2010 Mr JR Cameron

[34]2701213/2010 Mr TS Gillies

[35]2701214/2010 Mrs I Strawson

[36]3101361/2010 Mr B Heneghan

[37]3101362/2010 Mr J McMillan

[38]3101363/2010 Mr DH Wood

[39]3101364/2010 Mr WR Johnson

[40]3101365/2010 Mr AR Baker

[41]3101366/2010 Miss SA Doherty

[42]3101367/2010 Mr PA Harrison

[43]3101368/2010 Mr B Jones

[44]3101369/2010 Mr SD Reay

[45]3101370/2010 Mrs A Wallace

[46]3101371/2010 Mr JG Crombie

[47]3101394/2010 Miss S Bentley Case no: 3100962/2010 and 280 others

[48]3101395/2010 Mr B Cammell

[49]3101396/2010 Mr J Fairless

[50]3101397/2010 Mr H Orton

[51]3101398/2010 Mr AW Smith

[52]3101399/2010 Mr P Verschueren

[53]3101408/2010 Mr P Boucher

[54]3101735/2010 Mr D Hendrie

[55]3101736/2010 Mr WJ Loughlin

[56]3101737/2010 Mr DA McBride

[57]3101738/2010 Mr JM Wilson

[58]3101742/2010 Mr DJ Appleton

[59]3101743/2010 Mr PE Maxwell

[60]3101744/2010 Mr N Svonja

[61]3101745/2010 Mr M Harris

[62]3101746/2010 Mr HG Price

[63]3101747/2010 Mr M Saunders

[64]3101748/2010 Mr GD Bevans

[65]3101749/2010 Ms SB Stevenson

[66]3101750/2010 Mr BT Jones

[67]3101751/2010 Mr SN Fletcher

[68]3101753/2010 Ms L Dennehy

[69]3101754/2010 Mr IC Mills

[70]3101755/2010 Mr TJ Hillary

[71]3101756/2010 Mr SG Henderson

[72]3101757/2010 Ms P Robertson

[73]3101759/2010 Mrs JL Trickett

[74]3101760/2010 Mr DJ Turner

[75]3101762/2010 Mr AM Brown

[76]3101763/2010 Mr JA May

[77]3101764/2010 Mr C Jordan

[78]3101766/2010 Mr G Best

[79]3101910/2010 Mr GR Alderson

[80]3101912/2010 Mr C Anderson

[81]3101913/2010 Mr N Baird

[82]3101914/2010 Mr T Banks

[83]3101915/2010 Mrs J Bell

[84]3101916/2010 Mr P Blake

[85]3101917/2010 Mr P Blencowe

[86]3101918/2010 Mr A Board

[87]3101920/2010 Mr B Breton

[88]3101921/2010 Mr K Broadhead

[89]3101922/2010 Mr J Burns

[90]3101923/2010 Mr R Buxton

[91]3101924/2010 Mrs M Carmichael

[92]3101925/2010 Mr R Carr

[93]3101927/2010 Mr J Chappell

[94]3101928/2010 Mr L Churchard

[95]3101929/2010 Mr J Clark Case no: 3100962/2010 and 280 others

[96]3101930/2010 Mrs H Clegg

[97]3101931/2010 Mr C Clifford

[98]3101932/2010 Mr S Collins

[99]3101934/2010 Mrs J Colston

[100]3101935/2010 Mr R Croll

[101]3101936/2010 Mr R Cross

[102]3101937/2010 Mr D Crowther

[103]3101938/2010 Mr B Cuttell

[104]3101939/2010 Mr A Daisley

[105]3101940/2010 Mr A Denny

[106]3101941/2010 Mr M Digby

[107]3101942/2010 Mr J Docherty

[108]3101943/2010 Mr R Dudfield

[109]3101944/2010 Mr S Duncan

[110]3101945/2010 Mr B Edge

[111]3101946/2010 Mrs E Freeman

[112]3101947/2010 Mr J Geraghty

[113]3101948/2010 Mr N Giblin

[114]3101950/2010 Mr G Gilchrist

[115]3101951/2010 Mr J Gillespie

[116]3101952/2010 Mr A Glombek

[117]3101953/2010 Mr R Gonet

[118]3101954/2010 Mr N Goodall

[119]3101955/2010 Mr R Gordon

[120]3101957/2010 Mrs L Gray

[121]3101958/2010 Mr A Habgood

[122]3101959/2010 Mr P Harris

[123]3101960/2010 Mr J Hendry

[124]3101961/2010 Mr B Holme

[125]3101962/2010 Mr M Heron

[126]3101963/2010 Mr J Herrod

[127]3101964/2010 Mr P Hickson

[128]3101965/2010 Mr M Gallagher

[129]3101966/2010 Mr I Holden

[130]3101967/2010 Mr J Horn

[131]3101968/2010 Mr M Howard

[132]3101969/2010 Mrs I Hughes

[133]3101970/2010 Mr B Jarvis

[134]3101971/2010 Dr C Jackson

[135]3101972/2010 Mr J Iddiols

[136]3101973/2010 Mr D Keenan

[137]3101974/2010 Mr J King

[138]3101975/2010 Mr R Kiszka

[139]3101976/2010 Mr F Jackson

[140]3101977/2010 Mr M Johnson

[141]3101978/2010 Mr J Laing

[142]3101979/2010 Mr N Lochiel

[143]3101980/2010 Mr J Logue Case no: 3100962/2010 and 280 others

[144]3101981/2010 Mr R Leonard

[145]3101982/2010 Mr I MacDonald

[146]3101983/2010 Mr AD Major

[147]3101986/2010 Ms C Maynard

[148]3101987/2010 Mr I McCann

[149]3101988/2010 Mr G McGuinness

[150]3101989/2010 Mr J McKellar

[151]3101990/2010 Mr T McVey

[152]3101991/2010 Mr K McWilliams

[153]3101992/2010 Mr T Meanwell

[154]3101993/2010 Mr J Meldrum

[155]3101994/2010 Mr R Melling

[156]3101995/2010 Mr P Missen

[157]3101996/2010 Ms E Moran

[158]3101997/2010 Mr I Morton

[159]3101998/2010 Mr B Osbourne

[160]3101999/2010 Mr G Palethorpe

[161]3102000/2010 Mr J Peabody-Rolf

[162]3102001/2010 Ms D Peake

[163]3102003/2010 Mr G Raffel

[164]3102004/2010 Mr D Ralston

[165]3102006/2010 Mr M Restorick

[166]3102007/2010 Mr P Richardson

[167]3102008/2010 Mr R Richardson

[168]3102009/2010 Mr J Robertson

[169]3102010/2010 Mrs S Russell

[170]3102011/2010 Mr B Sadr-Salek

[171]3102012/2010 Mrs J Samson

[172]3102013/2010 Mr R Saunders

[173]3102014/2010 Mr G Schreiber

[174]3102015/2010 Mr M Scott

[175]3102016/2010 Mr G Seal

[176]3102017/2010 Mr N Shaw

[177]3102018/2010 Mr H Smith

[178]3102019/2010 Mr G Smith

[179]3102020/2010 Mr J Smith

[180]3102021/2010 Mr P Smith

[181]3102022/2010 Mr K Stainforth

[182]3102023/2010 Mr J Stewart

[183]3102024/2010 Mr R Storie

[184]3102025/2010 Ms J Swindin

[185]3102026/2010 Mr R Trickey

[186]3102027/2010 Mr N Turner

[187]3102028/2010 Mr K Warren

[188]3102029/2010 Mr A Watt

[189]3102030/2010 Mr J Wiles

[190]3102031/2010 Mr K Wilcock

[191]3102032/2010 Mr W Whigham Case no: 3100962/2010 and 280 others

[192]3102033/2010 Mr B Williams

[193]3102034/2010 Mr C Williams

[194]3102035/2010 Mr D Wilson

[195]3102036/2010 Mr R Williams

[196]3102037/2010 Mr E Woods

[197]3102308/2010 Ms JM MacDonald

[198]3102309/2010 Mr S Aldridge

[199]3102310/2010 Mr M Bromley

[200]3102312/2010 Ms M Burrows

[201]3102313/2010 Mr D Busch

[202]3102314/2010 Mrs M Cordina

[203]3102315/2010 Mr R Cornford

[204]3102316/2010 Ms G Cure

[205]3102318/2010 Mr K Dunn

[206]3102319/2010 Mrs D Fellows

[207]3102320/2010 Ms H Fellows

[208]3102321/2010 Ms D Fenwick

[209]3102322/2010 Mr R Gale

[210]3102324/2010 Mr C Harris

[211]3102325/2010 Ms J Heath

[212]3102326/2010 Mr M Kenyon

[213]3102327/2010 Mr D King

[214]3102328/2010 Mrs D Lindsay

[215]3102329/2010 Mr S Ljubbisavljevic

[216]3102330/2010 Mr C Mackie

[217]3102331/2010 Mr C Mills

[218]3102332/2010 Ms A Moody

[219]3102333/2010 Mr D Morgan

[220]3102335/2010 Ms J Mullins

[221]3102336/2010 Mr C Naik

[222]3102337/2010 Mr I Paul

[223]3102338/2010 Ms B Penney

[224]3102339/2010 Mr P Schofield

[225]3102340/2010 Mr P Seaman

[226]3102343/2010 Mr M Shannon

[227]3102344/2010 Mr P Speight

[228]3102345/2010 Mr K Spinks

[229]3102347/2010 Mr I Stevenson

[230]3102748/2010 Mr CW Bracey

[231]3102749/2010 Mr RA Canner

[232]3102750/2010 Mr AC Clow

[233]3102753/2010 Ms M Shanks

[234]3102754/2010 Mr I Mitchell

[235]3102962/2010 Mr A Donnison

[236]3103083/2010 Mr A Wilson

[237]3103088/2010 Mr J Carney

[238]3103162/2010 Ms MS Meredith

[239]3103163/2010 Mr V Cox Case no: 3100962/2010 and 280 others

[240]3103164/2010 Mr AJ Osmond

[241]3103165/2010 Mr AA Harmer

[242]3103166/2010 Mr KS Murray

[243]3103167/2010 Mr DG Langford

[244]3103168/2010 Mr R Gadd

[245]3103170/2010 Ms LM Millinson

[246]3103172/2010 Mr DF Fairall

[247]3103173/2010 Mr RP Thornley

[248]3103174/2010 Ms CG Issac

[249]3103175/2010 Mr MW Wood

[250]3103176/2010 Ms S Ross

[251]3103177/2010 Ms RA Rutherford

[252]3103178/2010 Mr I Noble

[253]3103179/2010 Mr J Overstall

[254]3103180/2010 Mr G Brenner

[255]3103204/2010 Mr D McEwan

[256]3103261/2010 Mrs C De Montfalcon

[257]3103558/2010 Mr P Johnson

[258]3103746/2010 Mr AR Edwards

[259]3103839/2010 Mr M Gask

[260]3104137/2010 Mr D Ramsay

[261]1300076/2011 Mr MM Rigby

[262]3100018/2011 Mr PF Kelly

[263]3100460/2011 Mrs A O'Malley

[264]3101109/2011 Mr PW Dempsey

[265]3101217/2011 Mr N Mallam

[266]3101220/2011 Mr GM Cameron

[267]3101222/2011 Mr J Cavani

[268]3101223/2011 Mr JJ Black

[269]3101406/2011 Mr G Collier

[270]3101433/2011 Mr WR Stark

[271]3101435/2011 Mr M Horan

[272]3101630/2011 Mrs C Robertson

[273]3101656/2011 Mr JD Farrant

[274]3101791/2011 Mr JA O'Hara

[275]3101875/2011 Mr D Martin

[276]3101885/2011 Mr SJ Russell

[277]3101954/2011 Mr RD Edwards

[278]3101975/2011 Mr G Boyd

[279]3102039/2011 Mr R Hutchison

[280]3102041/2011 Mr DS Renshaw

[281]3102043/2011 Mr JE Ahern Case No: 3100962/2010 & 280 Others (See attached schedule) EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS Claimant: Mr KM Quaid & 280 Others First Respondent: IBM United Kingdom Ltd Second Respondent: IBM United Kingdom Holdings Ltd CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION Employment Tribunals Rules of Procedure 2013 Under the provisions of Rule 69, the schedule attached to the Dismissal Judgment sent to the parties on 11 November 2019, is corrected as set out in block type. _____________________________ Regional Employment Judge Pirani Date: 13 January 2020 SENT TO THE PARTIES ON 29 January 2020 FOR THE TRIBUNAL OFFICE Important note to parties: Any dates for the filing of appeals or reviews are not changed by this certificate of correction and corrected judgment. These time limits still run from the date of the original judgment, or original judgment with reasons, when appealing. Case No: 3100962/2010 & 280 Others (See attached schedule) EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS Claimant: Mr KM Quaid & 280 Others First Respondent: IBM United Kingdom Ltd Second Respondent: IBM United Kingdom Holdings Ltd