Mr A White and others v Utilitywise plc (In Administration) and Secretary of State for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy: 2500256/2019 and others
JUDGMENT
The claims of those claimants named on the attached schedule under S.189 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 are well founded. I make a Protective Award in respect of those said claimants who were employees dismissed as redundant on 13th February 2019, that the employer pay remuneration for the protected period which begins on 13th February 2019 and is for 90 days. The Recoupment Regulations apply. Employment Judge Johnson Date: 8 November 2019 2500256/2019 Mr Ashley White 2500258/2019 Mr Joseph Bell 2500260/2019 Miss Paige Chandler 2500261/2019 Mrs Laura Charlton 2500263/2019 Mr Jason Green 2500266/2019 Mr Scott Hopkins 2500267/2019 Miss Stacey Hudson 2500270/2019 Mr Jonathan Pullarp 2500271/2019 Mr Grant Robinson Case No: 2500256/2019 & others 2 2500272/2019 Miss Jade Rowan 2500275/2019 Mrs Heather Woodhouse 2500276/2019 Mr Michael Wylie 2500278/2019 Mr John Allman 2500280/2019 Mr Jason Havvas 2500283/2019 Mr George Tron 2500286/2019 Miss Brooke Charlton 2500289/2019 Miss Terri Harwood 2500290/2019 Mr Gurminder Jagdev 2500296/2019 Mr Stewart Jones 2500298/2019 Mr Alessandro Atzeni 2500300/2019 Mr Stuart Donnison 2500301/2019 Mr Wayne Morrison 2500302/2019 Mr Robert Murray 2500304/2019 Mr Jasbinder Rana 2500305/2019 Mrs Natalie Robson 2500308/2019 Mr David Wilson 2500309/2019 Mr Paul Wright 2500346/2019 Miss Amy Rollins 2500352/2019 Mr Liam Wilkinson 2500354/2019 Mr Scott Parkin 2500362/2019 Mrs Asal Houshmandi Shargh 2500363/2019 Mr Craig Wright 2500367/2019 Mr Chris Walker 2500369/2019 Mr John Flynn 2500377/2019 Mr Paul Storey 2500378/2019 Miss Sarah Bates 2500379/2019 Mr Christopher Conwa 2500382/2019 Miss Nicole Matues 2500384/2019 Mr Ian Curran 2500385/2019 Mrs Angela Dorothy 2500386/2019 Mr Geoffrey Smith 2500390/2019 Mr Brian Wilson 2500391/2019 Mrs Elaine Williams 2500392/2019 Mr Daniel Docherty 2500393/2019 Mr Matthew Routledge 2500394/2019 Mrs Pamela Dane 2500397/2019 Mrs Lesley Weightman 2500400/2019 Mr Christopher Charlton 2500401/2019 Miss Ellen Choumanidis 2500402/2019 Miss Elaine Clennell 2500405/2019 Mr Daniel Jones 2500406/2019 Miss Jamie Leigh Kirtley – 2500407/2019 Mr Jay Khaliq 2500409/2019 Mr Christopher Toole 2500410/2019 Mr Graeme Waggott 2500411/2019 Miss Amy Wemyss 2500412/2019 Mrs Camille Wright 2500413/2019 Mr Richard Stiles 2500415/2019 Ms Joanne Arries 2500416/2019 Mr Carl Dixon 2500418/2019 Miss Heather Barsby 2500422/2019 Mr David Heslop 2500423/2019 Mrs Lisa Robinson 2500436/2019 Mr Thomas Czekirda 2500441/2019 Mr Shaun O'Hare Case No: 2500256/2019 & others 3 2500450/2019 Miss Beth Applegarth 2500452/2019 Miss Amanda Harnett 2500453/2019 Miss Joanne Iley 2500454/2019 Mr Jamie Marshall 2500455/2019 Mr Lewis McKie 2500457/2019 Mr Jonathan Spence 2500459/2019 Mr Darren Taylor 2500471/2019 Mr Karl Blake 2500474/2019 Mrs Sarah Iceton 2500577/2019 Mr Lindsay Cleverdon 2500581/2019 Mr Liam Barrett 2500582/2019 Mr Scott Ilderton 2500584/2019 Miss Siobhon Park 2500586/2019 Mr William Singh 2500599/2019 Mr Ryan Cowan 2500611/2019 Mrs Lynne Tufts 2500618/2019 Mr Derek Hosie 2500625/2019 Mrs Zeinab Lenton 2500626/2019 Mr Paul Martin 2500779/2019 Mr Paul Wintrip 2500782/2019 Mr Gareth Hall 2500783/2019 Mr Craig O'Neill 2500787/2019 Mr Sean Gleeson 2500813/2019 Mrs Jill 2500816/2019 Mr Grant Houston 2500818/2019 Mr Iain Lang 2500820/2019 Miss Tracey Park 2500828/2019 Mrs Jayne Metcalf 2500831/2019 Mr Gareth Charlton 2500847/2019 Miss Lauren Cox 2500853/2019 Miss Chloe Hogg 2500876/2019 Mr Gaurav Wadhawan 2500983/2019 Mr Trevor Watt 2500996/2019 Mr Ulrich Freyburger 2501003/2019 Mr Ian Simpson 2501017/2019 Mrs Lynn Roylance 2501021/2019 Ms Rachel Hudspith 2501045/2019 Miss Kirsty Swinney 2501057/2019 Mr Graham Bovet-White 2501838/2019 Mr Neil Edward Reid 2501844/2019 Miss Rachel Barclay 2501845/2019 Mr Ben Cardnell-Hesketh 2501846/2019 Mr Paul Fleckenstein 2501847/2019 Mrs Sara Kardas 2501848/2019 Mr Bob Siddle 2501849/2019 Mr David Simpson 2501851/2019 Mrs Victoria Tappenden 2501853/2019 Miss Lindsay Ballantine 2501854/2019 Mr Dean Bateman 2501855/2019 Mr Daniel 2501856/2019 Mr Kieran Carmichael 2501857/2019 Miss Rachel Chipp 2501858/2019 Mr Dimitri Price 2501859/2019 Ms Suzanne Dixon 2501860/2019 Mr Wayne Forrest 2501861/2019 Mr Ryan Killala-Forrest Case No: 2500256/2019 & others 4 2501862/2019 Mrs Julie Johnson 2501863/2019 Mrs Karen Kirby 2501865/2019 Mr Daniel Noble 2501866/2019 Miss Kathryn Sams 2501867/2019 Mr Paul Storey 2501868/2019 Mr Derek Walton 2501869/2019 Mrs Julia Wronkowski 2501870/2019 Mr Dale Forster 2501873/2019 Mr Dominic Baker 2501874/2019 Mrs Laura Charlton 2501875/2019 Mr Christopher Charlton 2501876/2019 Mr Samuel Lind 2501877/2019 Mr Steven Maguire 2501878/2019 Mr David McMullen 2501879/2019 Mr Ben Reed 2501880/2019 Mr Grant Paul Robinson 2501881/2019 Mrs Laura Warren 2501885/2019 Mr Keith Enfield 2501886/2019 Miss Theresa King 2501887/2019 Mr Jon Malcolm 2501888/2019 Mr Julien Malgras 2501889/2019 Mr Lee Rourke 2501891/2019 Mrs Suzy Wilson 2501892/2019 Mr Gavin Yannetta 2501894/2019 Mr Thibault 2501896/2019 Mr Anthony Hodgson 2501902/2019 Mr David Smith 2501905/2019 Mr Craig Clarkson 2501912/2019 Mr Neil Edward Reid 2501919/2019 Mr Christopher Allen 2501922/2019 Mr John Fox 2501923/2019 Miss Michelle Hayton 2501924/2019 Mr Kevin Hodgson 2501930/2019 Mr John Renforth 2501936/2019 Mr Christopher Chan 2501937/2019 Miss Tara Gray 2501938/2019 Ms Cloe Guenee 2501939/2019 Mr Mathieu Guenee 2501942/2019 Mr Damon Styles 2501947/2019 Mr Matthew Finbar Healy 2501995/2019 Miss Marie Finnigan 2502002/2019 Mrs Melanie Rae 2502013/2019 Mr Sebastien Forget 2502016/2019 Mr Anthony Heaton 2502018/2019 Mrs Leigh Oliphant 2502019/2019 Mr Michael Price 2502020/2019 Miss Karine Rochmann 2502028/2019 Mr Scott Burn 2502029/2019 Miss Paige Chandler 2502034/2019 Mr Adam Holding 2502036/2019 Mr Andrew Smith 2502039/2019 Mr Michael Tedder 2502042/2019 Miss Claire Balmbra 2502064/2019 Mr Keith Smith 2502073/2019 Miss Leslie Rouesnel 2502085/2019 Mr Silvio Cecchini Case No: 2500256/2019 & others 5 2502094/2019 Mr Denis Crook 2502099/2019 Mr Jonathan Radley 4107323/2019 Mr Michael Trainer Case No: 2500256/2019 10.15 Certificate of Correction – rule 69 March 2017 EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS Claimant: Mr A White & others (see attached schedule) Respondent: 1. Utilitywise Plc (In Administration)[2]Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION Employment Tribunals Rules of Procedure 2013 Under the provisions of Rule 69, the JUDGMENT sent to the parties on 12/11/2019, is corrected as set out in block type at pages 2-5. _____________________________ Employment Judge Johnson ______________________________ Date 8 November 2019 2500256/2019 Mr Ashley White 2500258/2019 Mr Joseph Bell 2500260/2019 Miss Paige Chandler 2500261/2019 Mrs Laura Charlton 2500263/2019 Mr Jason Green 2500266/2019 Mr Scott Hopkins 2500267/2019 Miss Stacey Hudson Case No: 2500256/2019 10.15 Certificate of Correction – rule 69 March 2017 2500270/2019 Mr Jonathan Pullarp 2500271/2019 Mr Grant Robinson 2500272/2019 Miss Jade Rowan 2500275/2019 Mrs Heather Woodhouse 2500276/2019 Mr Michael Wylie 2500278/2019 Mr John Allman 2500280/2019 Mr Jason Havvas 2500283/2019 Mr George Tron 2500286/2019 Miss Brooke Charlton 2500289/2019 Miss Terri Harwood 2500290/2019 Mr Gurminder Jagdev 2500296/2019 Mr Stewart Jones 2500298/2019 Mr Alessandro Atzeni 2500300/2019 Mr Stuart Donnison 2500301/2019 Mr Wayne Morrison 2500302/2019 Mr Robert Murray 2500304/2019 Mr Jasbinder Rana 2500305/2019 Mrs Natalie Robson 2500308/2019 Mr David Wilson 2500309/2019 Mr Paul Wright 2500346/2019 Miss Amy Rollins 2500352/2019 Mr Liam Wilkinson 2500354/2019 Mr Scott Parkin 2500362/2019 Mrs Asal Houshmandi Shargh 2500363/2019 Mr Craig Wright 2500367/2019 Mr Chris Walker 2500369/2019 Mr John Flynn 2500377/2019 Mr Paul Storey 2500378/2019 Miss Sarah Bates 2500379/2019 Mr Christopher Conway 2500382/2019 Miss Nicole Matues 2500384/2019 Mr Ian Curran 2500385/2019 Mrs Angela Dorothy 2500386/2019 Mr Geoffrey Smith 2500390/2019 Mr Brian Wilson 2500391/2019 Mrs Elaine Williams 2500392/2019 Mr Daniel Docherty 2500393/2019 Mr Matthew Routledge 2500394/2019 Mrs Pamela Dane 2500397/2019 Mrs Lesley Weightman 2500400/2019 Mr Christopher Charlton 2500401/2019 Miss Ellen Choumanidis 2500402/2019 Miss Elaine Clennell 2500405/2019 Mr Daniel Jones 2500406/2019 Miss Jamie Leigh Kirtley 2500407/2019 Mr Jay Khaliq 2500409/2019 Mr Christopher Toole 2500410/2019 Mr Graeme Waggott 2500411/2019 Miss Amy Wemyss 2500412/2019 Mrs Camille Wright 2500413/2019 Mr Richard Stiles 2500415/2019 Ms Joanne Arries 2500416/2019 Mr Carl Dixon 2500418/2019 Miss Heather Barsby 2500422/2019 Mr David Heslop 2500423/2019 Mrs Lisa Robinson 2500436/2019 Mr Thomas Czekirda Case No: 2500256/2019 10.15 Certificate of Correction – rule 69 March 2017 2500441/2019 Mr Shaun O'Hare 2500450/2019 Miss Beth Applegarth 2500452/2019 Miss Amanda Harnett 2500453/2019 Miss Joanne Iley 2500454/2019 Mr Jamie Marshall 2500455/2019 Mr Lewis McKie 2500457/2019 Mr Jonathan Spence 2500459/2019 Mr Darren Taylor 2500471/2019 Mr Karl Blake 2500474/2019 Mrs Sarah Iceton 2500577/2019 Mr Lindsay Cleverdon 2500581/2019 Mr Liam Barrett 2500582/2019 Mr Scott Ilderton 2500584/2019 Miss Siobhon Park 2500586/2019 Mr William Singh 2500599/2019 Mr Ryan Cowan 2500611/2019 Mrs Lynne Tufts 2500618/2019 Mr Derek Hosie 2500625/2019 Mrs Zeinab Lenton 2500626/2019 Mr Paul Martin 2500779/2019 Mr Paul Wintrip 2500782/2019 Mr Gareth Hall 2500783/2019 Mr Craig O'Neill 2500787/2019 Mr Sean Gleeson 2500813/2019 Mrs Jill Cunliffe 2500816/2019 Mr Grant Houston 2500818/2019 Mr Iain Lang 2500820/2019 Miss Tracey Park 2500828/2019 Mrs Jayne Metcalf 2500831/2019 Mr Gareth Charlton 2500847/2019 Miss Lauren Cox 2500853/2019 Miss Chloe Hogg 2500876/2019 Mr Gaurav Wadhawan 2500983/2019 Mr Trevor Watt 2500996/2019 Mr Ulrich Freyburger 2501003/2019 Mr Ian Simpson 2501017/2019 Mrs Lynn Roylance 2501021/2019 Ms Rachel Hudspith 2501045/2019 Miss Kirsty Swinney 2501057/2019 Mr Graham Bovet-White 2501838/2019 Mr Neil Edward Reid 2501844/2019 Miss Rachel Barclay 2501845/2019 Mr Ben Cardnell-Hesketh 2501846/2019 Mr Paul Fleckenstein 2501847/2019 Mrs Sara Kardas 2501848/2019 Mr Bob Siddle 2501849/2019 Mr David Simpson 2501851/2019 Mrs Victoria Tappenden 2501853/2019 Miss Lindsay Ballantine 2501854/2019 Mr Dean Bateman 2501855/2019 Mr Daniel Carmichael 2501856/2019 Mr Kieran Carmichael 2501857/2019 Miss Rachel Chipp 2501858/2019 Mr Dimitri Price 2501859/2019 Ms Suzanne Dixon 2501860/2019 Mr Wayne Forrest 2501861/2019 Mr Ryan Killala-Forrest Case No: 2500256/2019 10.15 Certificate of Correction – rule 69 March 2017 2501862/2019 Mrs Julie Johnson 2501863/2019 Mrs Karen Kirby 2501865/2019 Mr Daniel Noble 2501866/2019 Miss Kathryn Sams 2501867/2019 Mr Paul Storey 2501868/2019 Mr Derek Walton 2501869/2019 Mrs Julia Wronkowski 2501870/2019 Mr Dale Forster 2501873/2019 Mr Dominic Baker 2501874/2019 Mrs Laura Charlton 2501875/2019 Mr Christopher Charlton 2501876/2019 Mr Samuel Lind 2501877/2019 Mr Steven Maguire 2501878/2019 Mr David McMullen 2501879/2019 Mr Ben Reed 2501880/2019 Mr Grant Paul Robinson 2501881/2019 Mrs Laura Warren 2501885/2019 Mr Keith Enfield 2501886/2019 Miss Theresa King 2501887/2019 Mr Jon Malcolm 2501888/2019 Mr Julien Malgras 2501889/2019 Mr Lee Rourke 2501891/2019 Mrs Suzy Wilson 2501892/2019 Mr Gavin Yannetta 2501894/2019 Mr Thibault Boyer 2501896/2019 Mr Anthony Hodgson 2501902/2019 Mr David Smith 2501905/2019 Mr Craig Clarkson 2501912/2019 Mr Neil Edward Reid 2501919/2019 Mr Christopher Allen 2501922/2019 Mr John Fox 2501923/2019 Miss Michelle Hayton 2501924/2019 Mr Kevin Hodgson 2501930/2019 Mr John Renforth 2501936/2019 Mr Christopher Chan 2501937/2019 Miss Tara Gray 2501938/2019 Ms Cloe Guenee 2501939/2019 Mr Mathieu Guenee 2501942/2019 Mr Damon Styles 2501947/2019 Mr Matthew Finbar Healy 2501995/2019 Miss Marie Finnigan 2502002/2019 Mrs Melanie Rae 2502013/2019 Mr Sebastien Forget 2502016/2019 Mr Anthony Heaton 2502018/2019 Mrs Leigh Oliphant 2502019/2019 Mr Michael Price 2502020/2019 Miss Karine Rochmann 2502028/2019 Mr Scott Burn 2502029/2019 Miss Paige Chandler 2502034/2019 Mr Adam Holding 2502036/2019 Mr Andrew Smith 2502039/2019 Mr Michael Tedder 2502042/2019 Miss Claire Balmbra 2502064/2019 Mr Keith Smith 2502073/2019 Miss Leslie Rouesnel 2502085/2019 Mr Silvio Cecchini 2502094/2019 Mr Denis Crook Case No: 2500256/2019 10.15 Certificate of Correction – rule 69 March 2017 2502099/2019 Mr Jonathan Radley 4107323/2019 Mr Michael Trainer Important note to parties: Any dates for the filing of appeals or reviews are not changed by this certificate of correction and corrected judgment. These time limits still run from the date of the original judgment, or original judgment with reasons, when appealing. Case No:2500256/2019 6.8 Judgment on Withdrawal rule 52 EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS Claimant: Mr A White & others (see schedule) Respondent: 1. Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy 2. Utilitywise