Ms J Todd and Others v Famously Proper Ltd (In Administration): 2208018/2023 and Others
[1]In relation to the claimants named in Schedule 2 to this judgment only;1.1 Famously Proper Limited (in administration) failed to adequately comply with a requirement of section 188 of the Trade Union & Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 and their claim for a protective award brought under section 189 of the Trade Union & Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 succeeds.1.2 Famously Proper Limited (in administration) is ordered to pay remuneration (i.e. a protective award) to the claimants named in Schedule 2 for a protected period of 90 days beginning on 13 January 2023 (being the date on which the first of the dismissals to which the complaint relates took effect) to those claimants.[2]All of the remaining protective award claims brought by the claimants named in Schedule 3 are dismissed on withdrawal. The unfair dismissal claims[3]All of the Claimants’ claims against the First Respondent of unfair dismissal are dismissed on withdrawal. The automatic unfair dismissal claims[4]All of the Claimants’ claims against the First Respondent of automatic unfair dismissal under s103A Employment Rights Act 1996 (“ERA 1996”) are dismissed on withdrawal. The detriment claims[5]All of the Claimants’ claims against the First Respondent that they suffered a detriment under section 47B Employment Rights Act 1996 are dismissed on withdrawal. Claims against the Second and Third Respondents[6]For the avoidance of doubt, this judgment does not apply to the remaining section 47B ERA 1996 claims brought by the following claimants against the Second and Third Respondents: Ms Jennifer Todd Case No: 2208018/2023 Mr Robert Bryan Case No: 2208021/2023 Mr Matthew Banks Case No: 2208019/2023 Mr Jonathon Bromley Case No: 2208020/2023 Ms Stella Smith Case No: 2208047/2023 Costs[7]There is no order requiring any of the Claimants or the First Respondent to pay or reimburse any other party’s costs in relation to the claims brought by the Claimants referred to in Schedule 1 against the First Respondent and each party shall bear their own costs in relation to those claims. Case Number 2208018/2023 and others . 3 Employment Judge Webster Date: 4 June 2024 JUDGMENT and SUMMARY SENT to the PARTIES ON 11 June 2024 .................................................................................. ……………………………………………………………… For the Tribunal Office Case Number 2208018/2023 and others . 4 SCHEDULE 1 – ALL CLAIMANTS Ms Jennifer Todd Case No: 2208018/2023 Mr Matthew Banks Case No: 2208019/2023 Mr Jonathan Bromley Case No: 2208020/2023 Mr Robert Bryan Case No: 2208021/2023 Ms Hannah Chadwick Case No: 2208022/2023 Mr Charlie Dobb Case No: 2208023/2023 Mr Jacob Dowdswell Case No: 2208024/2023 Ms Stella Smith Case No: 2208047/2023 Ms Katie Yasemin Erceylan Case No: 2208025/2023 Ms Tabitha Gauntlett Case No: 2208026/2023 Mr Fouad Ghoul Case No: 2208027/2023 Ms Julia Makarova Case No: 2208028/2023 Ms Amy Louise Maskill Case No: 2208029/2023 Mr Neil McNab Case No: 2208030/2023 Ms Sultan Claudia Mirela Case No: 2208031/2023 Mr Joshua Molloy Case No: 2208032/2023 Ms Katryna Moncenko Case No: 2208033/2023 Mr Oralnto Pouikis Case No: 2208034/2023 Mr William Rice Case No: 2208035/2023 Mr Ahmad Sadallah Case No: 2208036/2023 Mr Anoop Sasikumar Case No: 2208037/2023 Mr Boris Smolenschii Case No: 2208038/2023 Ms Kinga Sobieraj Case No: 2208039/2023 Mr Avinash Sukkooba Case No: 2208040/2023 Ms Emese Monika Szeles Case No: 2208041/2023 Ms Katalin Szucs Case No: 2208042/2023 Mr Mate Toth Case No: 2208043/2023 Mr David White Case No: 2208044/2023[29]Mr Gabriel Wormald-Smith Case No: 2208045/2023 Case Number 2208018/2023 and others . 5 SCHEDULE 2 – CLAIMANTS WHOSE PROTECTIVE AWARD CLAIM SUCCEEDS Mr Matthew Banks Case No: 2208019/2023 Mr Jonathan Bromley Case No: 2208020/2023 Ms Hannah Chadwick Case No: 2208022/2023 Mr Charlie Dobb Case No: 2208023/2023 Mr Jacob Dowdswell Case No: 2208024/2023 Ms Stella Smith Case No: 2208047/2023 Ms Katie Yasemin Erceylan Case No: 2208025/2023 Ms Tabitha Gauntlett Case No: 2208026/2023 Mr Fouad Ghoul Case No: 2208027/2023 Ms Julia Makarova Case No: 2208028/2023 Ms Amy Louise Maskill Case No: 2208029/2023 Mr Joshua Molloy Case No: 2208032/2023 Ms Katryna Moncenko Case No: 2208033/2023 Mr William Rice Case No: 2208035/2023 Mr Ahmad Sadallah Case No: 2208036/2023 Mr Anoop Sasikumar Case No: 2208037/2023 Mr Boris Smolenschii Case No: 2208038/2023 Mr David White Case No: 2208044/2023[19]Mr Gabriel Wormald-Smith Case No: 2208045/2023 Case Number 2208018/2023 and others . 6 SCHEDULE 3 – CLAIMANTS WHOSE PROTECTIVE AWARD CLAIMS ARE DISMISSED ON WITHDRAWAL Ms Jennifer Todd Case No: 2208018/2023 Mr Robert Bryan Case No: 2208021/2023 Mr Neil McNab Case No: 2208030/2023 Ms Sultan Claudia Mirela Case No: 2208031/2023 Mr Oralnto Pouikis Case No: 2208034/2023 Ms Kinga Sobieraj Case No: 2208039/2023 Mr Avinash Sukkooba Case No: 2208040/2023 Ms Emese Monika Szeles Case No: 2208041/2023 Ms Katalin Szucs Case No: 2208042/2023 Mr Mate Toth Case No: 2208043/2023