Mr H Ford and Others v Zishan Zaman and Northstar Hotels Ltd: 1803071/2020
JUDGMENT
[1]The claims against the Second respondent Northstar Hotels Ltd as set out in the schedule to this judgment are well-founded and succeed.[2]The following claims are dismissed as they are duplicate claims: 1803820/2020 – Mr H Ford 1804384/2020 – Mrs K Liversedge 1804385/2020 – Ms C Ignatovich 1804390/2020 – Mrs K Liversedge 1804391/2020 – Ms C Ignatovich 1804392/2020 – Mrs K Liversedge 1804393/2020 – Ms C Ignatovich 1805023/2020 – Mr R Vernezze 1805024/2020 – Ms J Taylor 1806311/2020 – Mr R Vernezze 1806312/2020 – Mrs A Maris[3]Remedy judgments are to be provided in respect of the successful claims.[4]The claims of public interest disclosure detriment and dismissal are dismissed. Case Number: 1803071/2020 and others 2 of 3[5]Those claimants who were made redundant and who had not made a claim for a protective award were allowed to amend their claims to include claim for a protective award under section 189 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992. Those claims are well-founded and succeed.[6]Further applications to amend were granted in respect of the claims as set out in the attached schedule. Employment Judge Shepherd 22 June 2021 : Schedule of claims 1803071/2020 Mr H Ford – Notice pay, Failure to provide Written pay statement, Redundancy, Protective award, Unfair dismissal, Unauthorised deduction from wages, outstanding holiday pay. 1803826/2020 Mr P Newsome – Redundancy, Protective award, Unauthorised deduction from wages, outstanding holiday pay. 1803910/2020 Mr S Ladlow – Unauthorised deduction from wages. 1804383/2020 Ms C Ignatovich – Notice pay, Protective award, Redundancy, Unfair dismissal, Unauthorised deduction from wages. 1804386/2020 Mrs K Liversedge – Notice pay, Protective award, Redundancy, Unfair dismissal, Unauthorised deduction from wages, outstanding holiday pay. 1804900/2020 Mrs K Mappin Unauthorised deduction from wages, outstanding annual leave. 1804996/2020 Ms J Taylor – Unfair dismissal and unauthorised deduction from wages. 1804997/2020 Mr R Vernezze – Unauthorised deduction from wages, Unfair dismissal. Case Number: 1803071/2020 and others 3 of 3 1805163/2020 Mrs A Maris – Redundancy payment, Protective award, Unfair dismissal, Unauthorised deduction from wages, Failure to provide Written particulars. 185300/2020 Ms H Robb – Notice pay, Redundancy payment, Protective award, Unfair dismissal, Unauthorised deduction from wages. 185245/2020 Mr C Smith – Unauthorised deduction from wages, unfair dismissal. 1805412/2020 Mr J Robb – Unauthorised deduction from wages. 1805437/2020 Mr A Brown – Unauthorised deduction from wages, outstanding holiday pay 186309/2020 Ms J Taylor – Unauthorised deduction from wages, unfair dismissal, holiday pay. Case Number: 1803071/2020 and others 1 of 4 EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNALS Claimant: Mr H Ford and others (See attached Schedule) First Respondent: Zishan Zaman Second Respondent: Northstar Hotels Ltd Heard on: 22 June 2021 This has been a remote hearing, by CVP video link Before: Employment Judge Shepherd Appearances: For the claimants: Mr R Vernezze. For the respondents: No appearance REMEDYJUDGMENT 1. The second respondent Northstar Hotels Ltd is ordered to pay to the claimants the following amounts: 1803071/2020 Mr H Ford Notice pay – £2,256.00 Redundancy/Unfair dismissal – £3,948.00. Unauthorised deduction from wages – £2,256.00. Holiday pay – £214.52. Total monetary award £8,674.52. It is declared that there was a failure to provide a written pay statement – no monetary award is made. A protective award under section 189(3) to this claimant remuneration for the period of 90 days beginning on 10 June 2020. Case Number: 1803071/2020 and others 2 of 4 1803826/2020 Mr P Newsome Redundancy – £652.50 Unauthorised deduction from wages – £1,885.00 Holiday pay – £176.30. Total monetary award £2,713.80. A protective award under section 189(3) to this claimant remuneration for the period of 90 days beginning on 10 June 2020. 1803910/2020 Mr S Ladlow Unauthorised deduction from wages £4,239.44. Total monetary award £4,239.44 1804383/2020 Ms C Ignatovich Notice pay – £3,024.00. Redundancy/Unfair dismissal – £5,557.50, Unauthorised deduction from wages – £3420.00 Total monetary award £12,001.50. A protective award under section 189(3) to this claimant remuneration for the period of 90 days beginning on 10 June 2020. 1804386/2020 Mrs K Liversedge Notice pay – £3,432.00. Redundancy/Unfair dismissal – £6,120.00. Unauthorised deduction from wages – £3,325.60 Holiday pay – £286.00. Total monetary award £13,163.60 A protective award under section 189(3) to this claimant remuneration for the period of 90 days beginning on 10 June 2020. 1804900/2020 Mrs K Mappin Unauthorised deduction from wages £2,013.00 Holiday pay – £450.00. Total monetary award £2,463.00 Case Number: 1803071/2020 and others 3 of 4 1804996/2020 Ms J Taylor Unauthorised deduction from wages £4,140.00. Unfair dismissal £4,830.00. Total monetary award £8,970.00 1804997/2020 Mr R Vernezze Unauthorised deduction from wages £4,371.96 Unfair dismissal £6,454.00. Total monetary award £10,825.96 1805163/2020 Mrs A Maris Redundancy payment/Unfair dismissal £1,300.00 Unauthorised deduction from wages £3,917.54. Total monetary award £5,217.54 It is declared that there was a failure to provide a written pay statement – no monetary award is made. A protective award under section 189(3) to this claimant remuneration for the period of 90 days beginning on 10 June 2020. 1805300/2020 Ms H Robb Notice pay £226.00 Redundancy payment/Unfair dismissal £226.00. It is declared that there was a failure to provide a written pay statement – no monetary award is made. A protective award under section 189(3) to this claimant remuneration for the period of 90 days beginning on 10 June 2020. 1805245/2020 Mr C Smith Unauthorised deduction from wages £7734.58. Unfair dismissal £484.58 Total monetary award £8,219.16 1805412/2020 Mr J Robb Unauthorised deduction from wages £2,640.00. Case Number: 1803071/2020 and others 4 of 4 Total monetary award £2,640.00 1805437/2020 Mr A Brown Unauthorised deduction from wages £4,598.00 Holiday pay £418.00. Total monetary award £5016.00 1806309/2020 Ms J Taylor Unauthorised deduction from wages £1,539.76. Unfair dismissal £200.00. Holiday pay £181.89. Total monetary award £1921.65.