Mr E Rodrigues and others v Royal Mail Group Ltd: 1404078/2022 and others
JUDGMENT
[1]The claims in Schedule 1, attached to this judgment, being claims solely for detrimental treatment under s.146 TULRCA 1992, are struck out and dismissed.[2]The claims in Schedule 2, being claims solely for detrimental treatment under s.146 TULRCA 1992 which have been withdrawn by the claimants, are dismissed upon withdrawal.[3]With respect to the claims in Schedule 3, being claims for(a) detrimental treatment under s.146 TULRCA 1992 and(b) unlawful deduction from wages, the s.146 TULRCA claims are struck out and the unlawful deduction from wages claims will be the subject of further directions.REASONS
[1]Commencing in around August 2022, the Communication Workers Union (CWU) and Royal Mail were engaged in a dispute over pay and terms and conditions. This resulted in a number of days of industrial action and strike days between August and December 2023. The strikes days were on the following days and for the following periods: i. 26 August – 27 August 2022 04.00-04.00 (24 hours) ii. 31 August – 1 September 2022 04.00-04.00 (24 hours) iii. 8 September 2022 04.00 – 04.00 (24 hours reduced from 48 due to death of the Queen) iv. 30 September- 2 October 2022 04.00-04.00 (48 hours) v. 13-14 October 2022 04.00-04.00 (24 hours) vi. 20-21 October 2022 04.00-04.00 (24 hours) vii. 25-26 October 2022 04.00-04.00 (24 hours) viii. 24-26 November 2022 04.00-04.00 (48 hours) ix. 30 November – 2 December 2023 04.00 – 04.00 (48 hours) x. 09-10 December 2022 04.00-04.00 (24 hours) xi. 11 December 2022 00.01 -20.00 xii. 14 -15 December 2022 04.00 -04.00 (24 hours) xiii. 15-16 December 2022 04.00-04.00 (24 hours) xiv. 23 -24 December 2022 04.00-19.00[2]Individual employees, some via the CWU, issued various non dismissal detriment claims in 2022 and 2023 arising out of the industrial dispute / industrial action which commenced in the Summer of 2022. These fell broadly into five categories: i. Unlawful deductions of wages relating to the stoppage of sick pay; ii. Unlawful deductions of wages relating to the non-payment of overtime iii. Trade union detriment in relation to the stoppage of sick pay iv. Trade union detriment in relation to the non-payment of overtime v. Other pay/detriment related claims arising out of the said dispute[3]A Presidential Case Management Order (PCMO) was issued on 13 March 2023 which provided that having regard to, among other things, the overriding objective under Rule 2 of the First Schedule to the Employment Tribunals (Constitution and Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013, all such claims be transferred to the Employment Tribunal at Bristol.[4]Claims (iii) – (v), above, were brought pursuant to section 146 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 (TULRCA) which provides that workers have a right not to be subjected to a detriment for taking part in trade union activities. The Court of Appeal had reversed a decision of the EAT in the case of Mercer and held that TULRCA does not protect employees from action short of dismissal. This decision had, at the time the of the PCMO, been appealed to the Supreme Court.[5]As such, it was determined that directions would be put into place whereby further information pertaining to the details of the various claims would be gathered and responded to pending the outcome of the further appeal to the Supreme Court. These directions included the identification of a maximum of 10 lead cases each within each of the 5 categories.[6]In the event, by judgment handed down on 17 April 2024, after a hearing on 12 and 13 December 2023, the Supreme Court affirmed the view of the Court of Appeal and the Employment Tribunal that a convention compliant interpretation of section 146 would amount to an impermissible judicial legislation and exceeded the proper confines of section 3 Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA). The Supreme Court found that section 146 TULCA was incompatible with Article 11, insofar as it fails to provide any protection against sanctions short of dismissal.[7]Section 3 of the HRA requires the courts to interpret primary legislation compatibly with the Convention unless the legislation itself makes it impossible to do so. However, it does not enable the court to change the substance of a provision from one where it says one thing into one that says the opposite. In this case, the Supreme Court determined that there is no reading of section 146 that would avoid having to make a series of policy choices with potentially far reaching practical ramifications. This, they found, would amount to impermissible judicial legislation rather than interpretation. Therefore, it was held that section 146 cannot be interpreted as providing the protection sought.[8]On 23 April 2024 the respondent wrote to CWU and the other claimants in this case requesting that they withdraw the detriment claims following the Supreme Court decision in Mercer.[9]Because claims remained, on 13 May 2024 the respondent wrote to the Tribunal requesting that the claims for trade union detriment be struck out on the basis that the Tribunal had no jurisdiction following the Mercer decision in the Supreme Court.[10]The matter then came before me at a further case management preliminary hearing on 5 June 2024. At that hearing, I determined that an open preliminary hearing would be listed on 31 July 2024 consider the respondent’s application to strike out the detriment claims as having no reasonable prospect of success. Notice of the hearing was also sent to unrepresented claimants in this multiple. They were also asked to let the tribunal know if they were unable to attend the hearing today. Directions were provided which included clarification of the strike out application.[11]The Respondent has since clarified that, in light of Mercer, it pursues its application under Rule 37(1)(a) ET Rules 2013 for all section 146 detriment claims. This rule provides that at any stage of the proceedings, either on its own initiative or on the application of a party, a Tribunal may strike out all or part of a claim on specific grounds including that it “has no reasonable prospect of success.” In short, it is argued that in the face of Mercer the Claimants have no reasonable prospect of success in pursuing claims which have been found by the Supreme Court to exceed the Employment Tribunal’s statutory jurisdiction.[12]In reply, it was clarified on behalf of the CWU claimants, that they do not suggest, and have not suggested, that any remedying legislation introduced by the UK Government is likely to have retrospective effect. Although the CWU claimants do not dispute the substance of the respondent’s application, and do not oppose it, they nonetheless seek a reasoned judgment striking out the claims because the claimants are considering an application to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) against the UK Government, which would include a claim for a breach of Article 11 and 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights (the Convention). In particular, the claimants note that a claim which is the subject of an application to the ECHR must first have been brought in the domestic forum. Moreover, article 35 of the Convention requires all domestic remedies to have been exhausted prior to an application to the ECHR.[13]Accordingly, because the section 146 detriment claims exceed the Employment Tribunal’s statutory jurisdiction they have no reasonable prospect of success and are therefore struck out. Regional Employment Judge Pirani 31 July 2024 8 August 2024 For the Tribunal: 1. 1403513/2022 Mr Steven Stuart 2. 1806797/2022 Mrs Karen Keyworth 3. 1807148/2022 Mrs Karen Keyworth 4. 1807149/2022 Mr Steven Wright 5. 1807171/2022 Mr Samuel Hardwick 6. 2410105/2022 Mr Lennie Taylor 7. 2602978/2022 Mr Andrew Abbott 8. 3315161/2022 Mr Rajinder Rattan 9. 3315217/2022 Mr Divyang Varma 10. 3315222/2022 Mr Liban Liban 11. 3315229/2022 Mr Haben Hagos 12. 3315232/2022 Mr Mengisteab Gebremeskel13. 3315308/2022 Mr Liban Ali14. 3315316/2022 Mr Erwin Tambyapin15. 1400069/2023 Ms Pamela Beech16. 1400071/2023 Mr Jacob Barreto17. 1400072/2023 Mr Francisco De Sousa18. 1400073/2023 Mr Godfrey Dias19. 1400074/2023 Mr Hilario Dias20. 1400075/2023 Mr Keith Greener21. 1400076/2023 Mr Pawel Kryczna22. 1400077/2023 Mr Albano Lourenco23. 1400078/2023 Miss Karen Milbourne24. 1400079/2023 Mr Paul Milligan25. 1400080/2023 Mrs Stacy Rocha26. 1400081/2023 Mrs Irene Rodrigues27. 1400082/2023 Mr Edwin Rodrigues28. 1400089/2023 Mrs Samantha Finney29. 1400090/2023 Ms Pamela Beech30. 1400091/2023 Mr Hilario Dias31. 1400092/2023 Mr Eldra Fernandes32. 1400192/2023 Mrs Harjinder Saran33. 1400194/2023 Mr Steve Pawson34. 1400195/2023 Mr Matthew Rodrigues35. 1400196/2023 Mr Olivio Fernandes36. 1400197/2023 Miss Karen Milbourne37. 1400198/2023 Mr Albano Lourenco38. 1400199/2023 Mrs Maria Junqueira39. 1400200/2023 Mrs Stacy Rocha40. 1400201/2023 Mr Hilario Dias41. 1400202/2023 Mr Godfrey Dias42. 1400203/2023 Mrs Irene Rodrigues43. 1400204/2023 Mr Francisco De Sousa44. 1400205/2023 Mr Edwin Rodrigues45. 1400206/2023 Mr Joao Vales46. 1400207/2023 Miss Lisa Ellis47. 1400208/2023 Mr Pawel Kryczna48. 1400209/2023 Mr Luis Fernandes49. 1400216/2023 Mr Alan Willis50. 1400218/2023 Mr Jonathan Shurey51. 1400219/2023 Mr Joao Vales52. 1400220/2023 Mr Hillario Monteiro53. 1400221/2023 Mrs Lata Gauncar54. 1400222/2023 Mr Albano Dias55. 1400223/2023 Mr Jacob Barreto56. 1400224/2023 Mr Lazaro De Souza57. 1400225/2023 Mr Wayne Claridge58. 1400226/2023 Mrs Arcangela Fernandes59. 1400227/2023 Mrs Netty Diniz60. 1400228/2023 Mr Francisco De Sousa61. 1400229/2023 Mr Mathews Rodrigues62. 1400230/2023 Mr Luis Fernandes63. 1400231/2023 Mr Gregorio Ferrao64. 1400232/2023 Mr Roney Rodrigues65. 1400233/2023 Mr Edwin Rodrigues66. 1400234/2023 Mr Vincy Dasilva67. 1400266/2023 Mr Lazaro De Souza68. 1400268/2023 Mr Luicio D'mellow69. 1400269/2023 Mr Hilario Dias70. 1400270/2023 Mr Godrey Dias71. 1400271/2023 Mrs Irene Rodrigues72. 1400272/2023 Mr Pawel Kryczna73. 1400273/2023 Mr Alan Willis74. 1400274/2023 Mr Johnathan Brown75. 1400275/2023 Mr Joao Vales76. 1400276/2023 Mr Edwin Rodrigues77. 1400277/2023 Mrs Maria Junqueira78. 1400278/2023 Mrs Syloia Lewis79. 1400279/2023 Mr Vincy Dasilva80. 1400281/2023 Mr Olivio Fernandes81. 1400282/2023 Mr Caetano Novas82. 1400283/2023 Mrs Lata Gauncar83. 1400350/2023 Mr Michael Bickley84. 1400352/2023 Mr Ali Peara85. 1400353/2023 Mr Jacob Barreto86. 1400354/2023 Mr Benjohnson Da Cunha87. 1400355/2023 Mr Vincy Da Silva88. 1400356/2023 Mr Lazaro De Souza89. 1400357/2023 Mr Albano Dias90. 1400358/2023 Mrs Netty Diniz91. 1400359/2023 Mr Olivio Fernandes92. 1400360/2023 Mr Luis Fernandes93. 1400361/2023 Mr Gregoria Ferrao94. 1400362/2023 Mrs Vijitha Jegan95. 1400363/2023 Mr Brent Johnson-Flippance96. 1400364/2023 Mrs Maria Junqueira97. 1400365/2023 Mr Henrique Junqueira98. 1400366/2023 Mr Albano Lourenco99. 1400367/2023 Mrs Karen Milbourne100. 1400368/2023 Mr Cactona Noaves101. 1400369/2023 Mrs Stacy Rocha102. 1400370/2023 Mr Antoneta Rodriques103. 1400371/2023 Mr Edwin Rodriques104. 1400372/2023 Mr Jonathan Surey105. 1400415/2023 Mr Nicholas Pring106. 1400416/2023 Mrs Lata Gauncar107. 1400417/2023 Mr Caetana Noaves108. 1400418/2023 Mr Lazaro De Souza109. 1400419/2023 Mr Vincy Da Silva110. 1400420/2023 Mr Olivio Fernandes111. 1400422/2023 Mr Hilario Dias112. 1400423/2023 Mr Joao Vales113. 1400424/2023 Mr Pawel Kryczna114. 1400425/2023 Mrs Vilma De Araujo115. 1400426/2023 Mr Godrey Dias116. 1400512/2023 Mrs Cindy Barrance117. 1400514/2023 Mr Wayne Claridge118. 1400515/2023 Mr Benjohnson Dacunha119. 1400516/2023 Mr Lazaro De Souza120. 1400517/2023 Mr Godfrey Dias121. 1400518/2023 Mr Hilario Dias122. 1400519/2023 Mr Albano Dias123. 1400520/2023 Mrs Netty Diniz124. 1400521/2023 Mrs Eldra Fernandes125. 1400522/2023 Mr Luis Fernandes126. 1400523/2023 Mr Gregorio Ferrao127. 1400524/2023 Mrs Lata Gauncar128. 1400525/2023 Mr Brent Johnson-Flippance129. 1400526/2023 Mr Pawel Kryczna130. 1400527/2023 Mr Albano Lourenco131. 1400528/2023 Mrs Karen Milbourne132. 1400529/2023 Mr Roney Rodrigues133. 1400530/2023 Mr Edwin Rodrigues134. 1400531/2023 Mr Henrique Junqueira135. 1400552/2023 Mr Stephen Kalter136. 1400613/2023 Mr Patrick Coleman137. 1400923/2023 Mrs Estelle Lockett138. 1400947/2023 Mr James Herbert139. 1400983/2023 Mr Terence Barnes140. 1400985/2023 Mr Steven Leasmith141. 1401386/2023 Mr Greg Slateford142. 1403527/2023 Mrs Maria Lyons143. 1801947/2023 Mr Robert Milthorpe144. 1801968/2023 Mr Yahya Bhayat145. 1801969/2023 Mr Ricaredo Gabriel146. 1801970/2023 Mr Gurzala Sultana147. 1801971/2023 Mr David Rowley148. 1801972/2023 Mr Kelby Ward149. 1801973/2023 Mr Nasir Ali150. 1801974/2023 Mr Nayaka Sree151. 1801975/2023 Mr Tesfayanas Teklehaymonot152. 1801976/2023 Mr Abdurrehman Hussain153. 1801977/2023 Mr Shamun Miah154. 1801978/2023 Mr Mohammed Ariss155. 1801979/2023 Mr Shaun Abbbott156. 1801980/2023 Mr Mohammed Adeel157. 1801981/2023 Mr Tanveer Ahmed158. 1801982/2023 Mr Imran Ali159. 1801983/2023 Mr Christopher Bean160. 1801984/2023 Mrs Lisel Clayton161. 1801985/2023 Mr Richard Coates162. 1801986/2023 Mr Martin Droco163. 1801987/2023 Mr Sydney Falinya164. 1801988/2023 Mr Ricaredo Gabriel165. 1801989/2023 Mr Reza Grouhi166. 1801991/2023 Mrs Rachel Hardy167. 1801992/2023 Mrs Nadeem Heder168. 1801993/2023 Mr Niel Hutton169. 1801994/2023 Mr Mohammed Ilayas170. 1801995/2023 Mr Suhel Jogee171. 1801996/2023 Mrs Manta Kapil172. 1801997/2023 Mr Sanjeev Kapil173. 1801998/2023 Mr Abdul Khan174. 1801999/2023 Mr Sajjad Khan175. 1802001/2023 Mr Amjid Khan176. 1802003/2023 Mr Michael Larbi-Wasty177. 1802004/2023 Mr Azer Mahmood178. 1802005/2023 Mr Tahir Mahmood179. 1802006/2023 Mr Usman Mehmood180. 1802007/2023 Mr Shamun Miah181. 1802008/2023 Mr Asad Mulla182. 1802009/2023 Mr Samuel Olalaye183. 1802010/2023 Mrs Mary Olalaye184. 1802011/2023 Ms Ronald Partner185. 1802012/2023 Mr Mohammed Quereshi186. 1802013/2023 Mr Mohammed Quereshi187. 1802014/2023 Mr Waqar Rafiq188. 1802016/2023 Mr Hafeez Suleman189. 1802017/2023 Mr Siraj Tailor190. 1802018/2023 Mrs Amanda Thompson191. 1802019/2023 Mr John Warutere192. 1802020/2023 Mr Ian Worrall193. 1802021/2023 Mr Zahoor Yaqub194. 2200251/2023 Mr Abdi Rahman Hassan195. 2200255/2023 Mr Phillip Joesph196. 2200346/2023 Mr Ismail Ibrahim197. 2200842/2023 Mr Babajinm Davies198. 2200843/2023 Mr Abdirashid Adan199. 2200844/2023 Mrs Manjit Sahota200. 2200846/2023 Mr Visuvanathar Bavaneethan201. 2301158/2023 Mr Tom O’Connor202. 2401140/2023 Mr Matthew Brown203. 2600207/2023 Mr Carl Wain204. 2600227/2023 Mr Mark Stapleton205. 2600821/2023 Mr Alexander Gascoyne206. 3301603/2023 Mrs Tsvetelina Tsvetanova207. 3311144/2023 Mr Timothy Aldons 1. 1310827/2022 Miss Leanne Toogood 2. 1310835/2022 Mrs Natalie Barry 3. 1807147/2022 Mr Peter Martin 4. 3312716/2022 Mr Babis Dani 5. 3315218/2022 Mr Baljinder Bains 6. 3315434/2022 Mr Mostafa Mohamed 7. 1300124/2023 Mr Simon Brownhill 8. 1301483/2023 Mr Mohammed Ahmed 9. 1301733/2023 Mr Karen Kemp 10. 1301786/2023 Mr Paul Gammon 11. 1400008/2023 Mr Andrew Galey 12. 1400323/2023 Mr Gregory Saunders 13. 1400411/2023 Mr Mark Watts 14. 1400616/2023 Mr Robin Chilcott 15. 1400715/2023 Mr Jonathan Andrews 16. 1400950/2023 Mr Neil Sheldon 17. 1401076/2023 Mr PAUL MILLER 18. 1801990/2023 Mrs Jacqueline Hardy 19. 1802002/2023 Mr Graham Kirwin 20. 2201123/2023 Mr Charlie O'Donaghue 21. 2201131/2023 Mr Michael Miller 22. 2201136/2023 Mrs Agnieszka Eldridge 23. 2201137/2023 Mr Jason Thake 24. 2201139/2023 Mr Robert Watson 25. 2201140/2023 Mr Ray Sexton 26. 2201146/2023 Mrs Leeann Newcombe 27. 2401573/2023 Mr Munaf Patel 28. 2402205/2023 Mrs Louise Collinson 29. 2402951/2023 Mr Philip Lunt 30. 2600579/2023 Mr Jonathan Higgins 31. 2600646/2023 Mr Mark Robinson 32. 3300710/2023 Mr Jamie Lynn 33. 3301724/2023 Mr Andrew Hanna 34. 3301739/2023 Mr John Harris 35. 3302556/2023 Mr Paul Allen 36. 3302608/2023 Mr Giuseppe Melia 37. 3302614/2023 Mr Tom Shone 38. 3302631/2023 Mr Glyn Rainbow 39. 3302647/2023 Mrs Russel Castellino 40. 3302648/2023 Ms Sheela Imrankhaleel 41. 3302649/2023 Ms Myat Khaing 42. 3302650/2023 Mrs Vimla Lallbahadoor 1. 1310825/2022 Mr Stephen Wood 2. 1310831/2022 Adil Mahmood 3. 1310834/2022 Mr Nathan Knowles 4. 1404078/2022 Mr Edwin Rodrigues 5. 1404079/2022 Mr Antonio Pereira 6. 1404080/2022 Mr Francisco Pereira Pereira 7. 1404081/2022 Mrs Lorraine Lovell 8. 1404082/2022 Mr Jacob Barreto 9. 1404083/2022 Miss Samantha Finney 10. 1404084/2022 Mr Caetano Novaes 11. 1404085/2022 Mr Piedade Fernandes 12. 1404086/2022 Mr Jonathon Brown 13. 1404087/2022 Ms Pamela Beech 14. 1404088/2022 Mrs Irene Rodrigues 15. 1404089/2022 Mr Godfrey Dias 16. 1404090/2022 Mr Teri Rodrigues 17. 1404091/2022 Mr Brent Flippance 18. 1404092/2022 Ms Sylvia Lewis 19. 1404093/2022 Mr Joao Vales 20. 1404094/2022 Mr Alan Willis 21. 1404095/2022 Mr Pawel Kryczna 22. 1404096/2022 Mr Ben Johnson Da Cunha 23. 1404097/2022 Mr Luis Fernandes 24. 1404098/2022 Mrs Arcangela Fernandes 25. 1404099/2022 Mr Lazaro De Sousa 26. 1404100/2022 Mr Vincy Da Silva 27. 1601653/2022 Mr Russell Garrett 28. 1601679/2022 Miss Nicole Williams 29. 1806699/2022 Mr Zayed Choudry 30. 1806732/2022 Mrs Lynne Sawyer 31. 1807273/2022 Mr Abdullah Al Ameri 32. 2410341/2022 Mr Lee Dwyer 33. 2410342/2022 Mr Alex Knight 34. 2502399/2022 Mr Gregory Bourne 35. 2502405/2022 Mr Richard Jubb 36. 2603215/2022 Mr Harpal Bhogal 37. 3306370/2022 Mr Khurrum Khan 38. 3313825/2022 Mr Paul Morin 39. 3315026/2022 Mrs Parimala Shah 40. 3315027/2022 Mrs Shova Thapa 41. 3315028/2022 Mr Kanayo Udeh 42. 3315029/2022 Mrs Rachael Walsh 43. 3315202/2022 Mr Steve Botwright 44. 3315314/2022 Mr Parminder Mangat 45. 3315348/2022 Mr Sukhpal Bains 46. 3315432/2022 Mr Faisal Asim 47. 3315436/2022 Mr Parmjit Singh 48. 3315454/2022 Mr Hardikkumar Patel 49. 1301710/2023 Mr Harnek Nahal 50. 1302164/2023 Mr Bob Johnson 51. 1302642/2023 Mrs Samantha Cragg 52. 1302655/2023 Mr Shaun Garrett 53. 1302681/2023 Mr Thomas Porter 54. 1400117/2023 Mr Andrew Fyfield 55. 1400491/2023 Mr Martin Castle 56. 1400493/2023 Mrs Stephanie Chudley 57. 1400496/2023 Mr Ian Moore 58. 1400497/2023 Mr James Powell 59. 1400502/2023 Mr Rory Hamilton 60. 1400503/2023 Mr Lee Chudley 61. 1400505/2023 Mr Leon Fox 62. 1400509/2023 Mr Michael Kazimierowicz 63. 1400510/2023 Mr David Beattie 64. 1400511/2023 Mr Marian Seneviratne 65. 1400679/2023 Mr Michael Sparks 66. 1400718/2023 Mr Stewart Tyrer 67. 1400734/2023 Mr Bentley Knight 68. 1400876/2023 Mr Andrew Weston 69. 1400914/2023 Mr Lee Phillips 70. 1400971/2023 Mr Garry Watson 71. 1401055/2023 Mrs Catherine Hartland 72. 1401075/2023 Mr Leigh Suitor 73. 1401077/2023 Mr Rekhmire Garcia 74. 1401087/2023 Mr Graham Hendey 75. 1401096/2023 Mr Raymond Harmer 76. 1401098/2023 Mr Barry Heppell 77. 1401141/2023 Mr Eugene Long 78. 1403374/2023 Mrs Rachel Daley 79. 1405772/2023 Mr Matthew Monk 80. 1600007/2023 Mr Michael Carney 81. 1600017/2023 Mr Mohammed P Khan 82. 1600019/2023 Mr Shakil Hussain 83. 1600020/2023 Mr Tehmoor Shah 84. 1600067/2023 Mrs Ashika Shah 85. 1600069/2023 Mr Zahid Khan 86. 1600070/2023 Mr Hader Zaman 87. 1600072/2023 Mr Mohammed Miah 88. 1600080/2023 Mr Fasal Khan 89. 1600082/2023 Mr Tony Brown 90. 1600126/2023 Mr David James 91. 1600128/2023 Mr Mohammed Faisan Khan 92. 1600129/2023 Mr Christopher Feehan 93. 1600317/2023 Mr Mohamed Sharif 94. 1600319/2023 Miss Ellie Kihlberg 95. 1600584/2023 Mr Karl Jewitt 96. 1600719/2023 Miss Melissa Hopkins 97. 1800013/2023 Mr Andrew Beatson 98. 1800014/2023 Mr John Wilson 99. 1800015/2023 Mr Keith Turner 100. 1800016/2023 Mrs Victoria Marsh 101. 1800161/2023 Mrs Hayley Mattocks 102. 1800814/2023 Mr Tony Noble 103. 1800815/2023 Mrs Lynne Sawyer 104. 1800816/2023 Mrs Caroline Hernandez 105. 1801488/2023 Mrs Victoria Marsh 106. 1802718/2023 Mr Andrew Humphrey 107. 1802719/2023 Mr Mohammad Asan 108. 1802720/2023 Mr Umair Bilal 109. 1802721/2023 Mr Barry Cummings 110. 1802722/2023 Mr Simon Dandy 111. 1802723/2023 Mr Jamie Dyer 112. 1802724/2023 Mr Matthew Hawksby 113. 1802726/2023 Mr Azer Hussain 114. 1802727/2023 Mr Ian Mcdermott 115. 1802728/2023 Mr Darren Moore 116. 1802729/2023 Mr Jose Suarez 117. 1804329/2023 Mr Steven Lewis 118. 2200249/2023 Mr Bipindra Patel 119. 2200250/2023 Mr Connor Mahon 120. 2200328/2023 Mr Menesh Taank 121. 2201109/2023 Mr Richard Pinder 122. 2201110/2023 Mrs Gemma Flindall 123. 2201111/2023 Mrs Tracy Knight 124. 2201112/2023 Mr Gareth Evans 125. 2201113/2023 Mrs Julia Fleck 126. 2201114/2023 Mrs Patricia Barnes 127. 2201115/2023 Mr Andrew Singleton 128. 2201116/2023 Mr Jitendra Makwana 129. 2201117/2023 Mr Robert Terrell 130. 2201118/2023 Mr Adam Warner 131. 2201119/2023 Mr Ahmed Intesar 132. 2201122/2023 Mr Guy Bishop 133. 2201124/2023 Mr Simon Ward 134. 2201125/2023 Mrs Julie Spurrier 135. 2201126/2023 Mr Gary Spurrier 136. 2201127/2023 Mrs Andrea Shepherd 137. 2201128/2023 Mr Matthew Moulding 138. 2201129/2023 Mr Paul Sargent 139. 2201132/2023 Mr Nedalu Barev 140. 2201133/2023 Mr Ertugrul Tamer 141. 2201134/2023 Mrs Karen Gower 142. 2201135/2023 Mr William Morgan 143. 2201138/2023 Mrs Julita Ciolczyk 144. 2201141/2023 Mr Robert Todd 145. 2201142/2023 Mr Mark Hurrell 146. 2201144/2023 Mr Jonathan Whipps 147. 2201145/2023 Mr Jacky Fong 148. 2201147/2023 Mr Liam Priest 149. 2201148/2023 Mr Duncan Codjoe 150. 2201149/2023 Mr Darren Finnerty 151. 2201151/2023 Mrs Mary Harvey 152. 2201152/2023 Mr Mark Tanner 153. 2201153/2023 Miss Laura Bigland 154. 2201188/2023 Mr Paul Tucker 155. 2201753/2023 Miss Diane Hutchinson 156. 2201765/2023 Mr Jason Turner 157. 2300353/2023 Mr Andrew Clark 158. 2300354/2023 Mr Dominic Reid 159. 2300355/2023 Mr Matthew Ashenden 160. 2300356/2023 Mr Benjamin Pelling 161. 2300607/2023 Mr Alex Poole 162. 2300637/2023 Mr Ashley Wibrew 163. 2300638/2023 Ms Sarie Hopkins 164. 2300640/2023 Mr Nicholas Hullet 165. 2300811/2023 Mr Benjamin Pelling 166. 2300813/2023 Mr Dominic Reid 167. 2300815/2023 Mr Matthew Ashenden 168. 2300816/2023 Mr Andrew Clark 169. 2300821/2023 Mr John Day 170. 2300914/2023 Mr Andrew Irving 171. 2301278/2023 Mrs Emma Hayward 172. 2301530/2023 Mr Neil Baksh 173. 2400023/2023 Mr Charles Birch 174. 2402072/2023 Mrs Bakula Patel 175. 2402073/2023 Mr Christopher McCarthy 176. 2402074/2023 Mr Paul Edwards 177. 2402075/2023 Mr Thomas Higgins 178. 2402076/2023 Mr Darren Mitchell 179. 2402077/2023 Mr Lee Fawcett 180. 2402078/2023 Mr Micheal Lowry 181. 2402079/2023 Mr David Ellard 182. 2402080/2023 Mr Graham Alty 183. 2402081/2023 Mr Ian Gore 184. 2402082/2023 Mr Drew Merchant 185. 2402083/2023 Mr Paul Faragher 186. 2402084/2023 Miss Jennifer Austin 187. 2402085/2023 Mr Raju Patel 188. 2402086/2023 Mr Charles Birch 189. 2402087/2023 Mr Russ Mcgeehan 190. 2402104/2023 Mrs Julie Ashworth 191. 2402187/2023 Mr Norman Telford 192. 2402189/2023 Mr Juned Manju 193. 2402202/2023 Mr Shakil Bapu 194. 2402203/2023 Mr Jacob Guzowski 195. 2402204/2023 Mr John Walker 196. 2402210/2023 Mr Mark Salmon 197. 2402212/2023 Mr Kevin Orrell 198. 2402213/2023 Mr Anthony Kirkup 199. 2402214/2023 Mr David Caine 200. 2402586/2023 Mr Christopher Bridge 201. 2403083/2023 Mr John Yates 202. 2407159/2023 Mr Christopher Anthony McCarthy 203. 2500085/2023 Mr Alfred Briggs 204. 2500086/2023 Mr Darren Bradley 205. 2500087/2023 Mrs Julie Campbell-Islam 206. 2500088/2023 Mr Mark Hamilton 207. 2500089/2023 Mr David Hamilton208. 2500090/2023 Mr James Hollyman209. 2500091/2023 Mr Daniel Martin210. 2500092/2023 Mr Jeffrey Nesbitt211. 2500093/2023 Mr David Person212. 2500094/2023 Mr Mattew Reay213. 2500095/2023 Mr Craig Salkeld214. 2500096/2023 Mr Gavin Saxby215. 2500097/2023 Mr Lee Willison216. 2500153/2023 Mr Shaun Reay217. 2500239/2023 Mr Andrew Rodger218. 2500340/2023 Mr Mark Wilkinson219. 2500367/2023 Mr Mark Soper220. 2600118/2023 Mr Robert Bailey221. 2600170/2023 Miss Rebecca Field222. 2600197/2023 Mr Aaron Rhodes223. 2600213/2023 Mr Richard Fraser224. 2600216/2023 Mr Dean Mills225. 2600238/2023 Mr Robert Taylor226. 2600249/2023 Mr Andrew Kiddier227. 2600269/2023 Mr Christopher Taft228. 2600310/2023 Mr Momodou Sowe229. 2600446/2023 Mr Gregg Blackham230. 2600542/2023 Mrs Cheryl Brooks231. 2600567/2023 Mr Ashley Thurman232. 2600576/2023 Miss Michelle McKillop233. 2600577/2023 Mr Paul Mews234. 2600578/2023 Mr Craig Wilson235. 2600653/2023 Mr Drew Jones236. 2600662/2023 Mr Patrick Ahern237. 2600708/2023 Mrs Karen Holmes238. 2600710/2023 Mr Mathew Hastilow239. 3200236/2023 Mrs Diane-Flore Yeou240. 3200237/2023 Ms Mabel Emetenana241. 3200238/2023 Mr Stephane Yeou242. 3200240/2023 Mr Mark Robinson243. 3200630/2023 Mr Lawrence Hammond244. 3200632/2023 Mr Christopher Geoffery Chandler245. 3300081/2023 Mr Olushola Adebiyi246. 3300131/2023 Mr Nandkishore Arora247. 3300136/2023 Mr Manoj Panicker248. 3300137/2023 Mr Talvinder Rehncy249. 3300155/2023 Mr Scott Woodley250. 3300156/2023 Mr Tony Allen251. 3300287/2023 Mr Aziz-Ur Rehman252. 3300289/2023 Mr Lamin Touray253. 3300309/2023 Mr Ihsan Ulhaq254. 3300362/2023 Mr Omavuayen Omi Ogbiru255. 3300444/2023 Mr Paul Morin256. 3300448/2023 Ms Usha Surve257. 3300483/2023 Mr Rajinder Kumar258. 3300506/2023 Mr Cumar Maxamed259. 3300623/2023 Mr Ian Voller260. 3300624/2023 Mr Lee Rogers261. 3300625/2023 Mr Kashif Mughal262. 3300626/2023 Mr Tushar Shah263. 3300650/2023 Miss Caroline Roullier264. 3301613/2023 Mrs Fiona Hogan265. 3301858/2023 Miss Melanie Mcmahon266. 3301868/2023 Mr Mohamed Omar267. 3302085/2023 Mr Gurmeet Singh Virk268. 3302175/2023 Mr Julian Travill269. 3302445/2023 Mr Rajinder Kumar270. 3302472/2023 Mr John Fisher271. 3302570/2023 Miss Clare Nudds272. 3302638/2023 Mr Toufik Abbas273. 3302640/2023 Mr Ajay Mukka274. 3302641/2023 Mrs Mathani Rajkumar275. 3302642/2023 Mrs Teena Rana276. 3302643/2023 Mrs Maninder Saberwal277. 3302644/2023 Mrs Harpreet Sidhu278. 3302645/2023 Ms Lai The279. 3302646/2023 Mr Ashok Vuppala280. 3302651/2023 Ms Faustina Rowland281. 3302652/2023 Mr Sharooz Shaukat282. 3302653/2023 Mrs Annet Rosil283. 3302654/2023 Mrs Radha Sodaghar284. 3302655/2023 Mrs Swarlanatha Chanda285. 3302656/2023 Mrs Shashi Mishra286. 3302657/2023 Mrs Charanjit Virk287. 3302658/2023 Mrs Umamaheswari Valipireddy288. 3302659/2023 Ms Cristina Campos289. 3304220/2023 Miss Natalie Duarte290. 3304276/2023 Mr Darren Green291. 3304974/2023 Mr Rajeshshal Rajesh Shah