Mrs J Fish and others v Falkirk Council: 100184/2010 and Others (see attached list)
JUDGMENT
The claims, having been withdrawn by the claimants are dismissed under Rule 52 of the Rules contained in Schedule 1 of the Employment Tribunals (Constitution and Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013. Employment Judge Frances Eccles Date of Judgment 17 August 2019 100184/2010 Mrs Jeanette Fish -v- Falkirk Council 100214/2010 Ms Linda Kirk -v- Falkirk Council 100302/2010 Mrs Mary Robertson -v- Falkirk Council 100382/2010 Mrs Sandra Coutts -v- Falkirk Council 100390/2010 Mrs Carol Howe -v- Falkirk Council 100769/2011 Ms Elanor McLean -v- Falkirk Council 103335/2011 Ms Catherine Roberts -v- Falkirk Council 103336/2011 Mrs Kay McLauchlan -v- Falkirk Council 103841/2011 Mrs Kathleen Lawlor -v- Falkirk Council 104517/2011 Mrs Ellen Donaldson -v- Falkirk Council 104518/2011 Mrs Ellen Donaldson -v- Falkirk Council 104519/2011 Mrs Chrystabel Murdoch -v- Falkirk Council 104520/2011 Mrs Catherine Thompsons -v- Falkirk Council 104523/2011 Mrs Evelyn Mills -v- Falkirk Council 104524/2011 Mrs Evelyn Mills -v- Falkirk Council 104525/2011 Mrs Helen Thomson -v- Falkirk Council 104526/2011 Mrs Helen Thomson -v- Falkirk Council 104530/2011 Mrs Janet Adamson -v- Falkirk Council 104531/2011 Mrs Janet Adamson -v- Falkirk Council 104532/2011 Mrs Isobel Kirkwood -v- Falkirk Council 104533/2011 Ms Isabella Stowe -v- Falkirk Council 104534/2011 Mrs Isobel Kirkwood -v- Falkirk Council 104535/2011 Ms Isabella Stowe -v- Falkirk Council 104536/2011 Ms Linda Hutchison -v- Falkirk Council 104537/2011 Mrs Suet Clark -v- Falkirk Council 104538/2011 Mrs Susan Mochar -v- Falkirk Council 104539/2011 Mrs Janice Binnie -v- Falkirk Council 104540/2011 Mrs Janice Binnie -v- Falkirk Council 104542/2011 Mrs Lorna Finlay -v- Falkirk Council 104777/2011 Mrs Yvonne Daly -v- Falkirk Council 104779/2011 Mrs Yvonne Daly -v- Falkirk Council 104982/2011 Mrs Deborah Seton -v- Falkirk Council 104984/2011 Mrs Deborah Seton -v- Falkirk Council 105517/2010 Ms Janette Forsyth -v- Falkirk Council 105519/2010 Ms Maria Gillespie -v- Falkirk Council 105520/2010 Ms Allison Gray -v- Falkirk Council 105521/2010 Ms Catherine Hendry -v- Falkirk Council 105522/2010 Ms Helen Liddle -v- Falkirk Council 105523/2010 Ms Sandra Logan -v- Falkirk Council 105524/2010 Ms Wilma McCulloch -v- Falkirk Council 105526/2010 Ms Mary McKinlay -v- Falkirk Council 105527/2010 Ms Linda McPeake -v- Falkirk Council Printed On: 24-Jan-2020 14:30 By: L Milne Page 1 of 9 105528/2010 Ms Sandra Norwood -v- Falkirk Council 105529/2010 Ms Jean Oliver -v- Falkirk Council 105532/2010 Mr Gordon Haxton -v- Falkirk Council 105587/2011 Mrs Gwen Gallacher -v- Falkirk Council 105588/2011 Mrs Lesley Russell -v- Falkirk Council 105589/2011 Ms Ann Curran -v- Falkirk Council 105590/2011 Mrs Margaret Price -v- Falkirk Council 105595/2011 Mrs Margaret Price -v- Falkirk Council 105597/2011 Ms Tracy Laird -v- Falkirk Council 105722/2011 Ms Margaret-Ann Marsh -v- Falkirk Council 105723/2011 Ms Margaret-Ann Marsh -v- Falkirk Council 105724/2011 Mrs Sharon Anderson -v- Falkirk Council 105725/2011 mrs Joan Campbell -v- Falkirk Council 105726/2011 Mrs Angela Carr -v- Falkirk Council 105727/2011 Mrs Angela Carr -v- Falkirk Council 105728/2011 Ms Gillian Quinn -v- Falkirk Council 105740/2010 Ms Mark Barnett -v- Falkirk Council 105851/2011 Ms Ellen Dibdin -v- Falkirk Council 105852/2011 Ms Ellen Dibdin -v- Falkirk Council 105853/2011 Ms Elizabeth Quinney -v- Falkirk Council 105854/2011 Ms Elizabeth Quinney -v- Falkirk Council 105855/2011 Ms Elizabeth Shanks -v- Falkirk Council 105856/2011 Ms Elizabeth Shanks -v- Falkirk Council 105858/2011 Mrs Susan Harrower -v- Falkirk Council 105859/2011 Mrs Edith Moon -v- Falkirk Council 105860/2011 Mrs Edith Moon -v- Falkirk Council 105861/2011 Mrs Susan Drummond -v- Falkirk Council 105865/2011 Mr Derek Craig -v- Falkirk Council 105867/2011 Ms Mary Kanikula -v- Falkirk Council 105869/2011 Mrs Lilias MacIntosh -v- Falkirk Council 105870/2011 Ms Rosemary McAteer -v- Falkirk Council 105871/2011 Ms Maureen McKell -v- Falkirk Council 105872/2011 Mrs Arlene McKeown -v- Falkirk Council 105873/2011 Mrs Myra Penman -v- Falkirk Council 105874/2011 Mrs May Ryan -v- Falkirk Council 106065/2011 Mrs Alice Hamilton -v- Falkirk Council 106093/2011 Mrs Anne Stewart -v- Falkirk Council 106096/2011 Mrs Jennifer Ellis -v- Falkirk Council 106212/2011 Mrs Kerry-Anne Fulton -v- Falkirk Council 106215/2011 Mrs Catriona Thomson -v- Falkirk Council 106218/2011 Ms Elizabeth Thomson -v- Falkirk Council 106220/2011 Mrs Ellen Turner -v- Falkirk Council Printed On: 24-Jan-2020 14:30 By: L Milne Page 2 of 9 106221/2011 Mrs Ellen Turner -v- Falkirk Council 106223/2011 Miss Karen Boyle -v- Falkirk Council 106227/2011 Mrs Yvonne Tollins -v- Falkirk Council 106228/2011 Mrs Yvonne Tollins -v- Falkirk Council 106249/2011 Mrs Ann Marie Ivory -v- Falkirk Council 106250/2011 Mrs Ellen Seel -v- Falkirk Council 106307/2011 Mrs Jane Patrick -v- Falkirk Council 106308/2011 Ms Eleanor McCutcheon -v- Falkirk Council 106309/2011 Mrs Sandra Hastings -v- Falkirk Council 106310/2011 Mrs Shirley Ann Coulter -v- Falkirk Council 106341/2011 Mrs Lynn Majorek -v- Falkirk Council 106343/2011 Mrs Ann Lapsey -v- Falkirk Council 106345/2011 Mrs Ishbel Stewart -v- Falkirk Council 106362/2011 Mrs Shirley Healer -v- Falkirk Council 106363/2011 Mrs Margo Ferguson -v- Falkirk Council 106364/2011 Mrs Valerie Crawford -v- Falkirk Council 106420/2011 Mrs Joanne Turnbull -v- Falkirk Council 106422/2011 Mrs Jessie Fallon -v- Falkirk Council 106670/2011 Mrs June Majorek -v- Falkirk Council 106671/2011 Mrs Helen Robertson -v- Falkirk Council 106672/2011 Ms Shirley Walsh -v- Falkirk Council 106674/2011 Ms Louisa McDowall -v- Falkirk Council 106721/2011 Mrs Shiona Arnott -v- Falkirk Council 106724/2011 Ms Donna Dunlop -v- Falkirk Council 106725/2011 Mrs Angela Weir -v- Falkirk Council 106728/2011 Ms Agnes Foster -v- Falkirk Council 106729/2011 Mrs Natalie Mackie -v- Falkirk Council 106731/2011 Mrs Natalie Mackie -v- Falkirk Council 106733/2011 Mrs Azra Afzal -v- Falkirk Council 106734/2011 Ms Laura Gallagher -v- Falkirk Council 106735/2011 Mrs Margaret Ainslie -v- Falkirk Council 106933/2011 Miss Linda Skinner -v- Falkirk Council 106934/2011 Mrs Katrina Nimmo -v- Falkirk Council 106935/2011 Mrs Marion Poodle -v- Falkirk Council 106936/2011 Mrs Elaine Monteith -v- Falkirk Council 106937/2011 Miss Linda Skinner -v- Falkirk Council 107002/2011 Mr Steven Desmond -v- Falkirk Council 107005/2011 Mrs Elize Wilkie -v- Falkirk Council 107007/2011 Mrs Kay Thornton -v- Falkirk Council 107008/2011 Mrs Florence Thomson -v- Falkirk Council 107012/2011 Mrs Angela Shanks -v- Falkirk Council 107017/2011 Mrs Alison Shadbolt -v- Falkirk Council Printed On: 24-Jan-2020 14:30 By: L Milne Page 3 of 9 107019/2011 Mrs Margaret White -v- Falkirk Council 107021/2011 Mrs Margaret White -v- Falkirk Council 107023/2011 Mrs Helen Young -v- Falkirk Council 107024/2011 Ms Ruth Binnie -v- Falkirk Council 107026/2011 Mrs Margaret Allan -v- Falkirk Council 107028/2011 Mrs Pamela Nelson -v- Falkirk Council 107032/2011 Mrs Caroline Kennedy -v- Falkirk Council 107034/2011 Ms Jennifer Gillespie -v- Falkirk Council 107036/2011 Mrs Elizabeth Dow -v- Falkirk Council 107037/2011 Mrs Helena Pearson -v- Falkirk Council 108737/2011 Mrs Sandra Hastings -v- Falkirk Council 108738/2011 Mrs Sandra Hastings -v- Falkirk Council 108742/2011 Mrs Billie Nairn -v- Falkirk Council 108745/2011 Mrs Jacqueline Ormond -v- Falkirk Council 108748/2011 Mrs Elaine McGeachy -v- Falkirk Council 108749/2011 Mrs Lesley Bell -v- Falkirk Council 108750/2011 Mrs Janice Caven -v- Falkirk Council 108751/2011 Mrs Dianne Crumley -v- Falkirk Council 108752/2011 Miss Carol Garner -v- Falkirk Council 108753/2011 Mrs Karen Girdwood -v- Falkirk Council 108754/2011 Miss Diane Greene -v- Falkirk Council 108755/2011 Ms Moira Louden -v- Falkirk Council 108756/2011 Mrs Eileen MacLean -v- Falkirk Council 108757/2011 Mrs Sylvia McMenemy -v- Falkirk Council 108758/2011 Mrs Sylvia McMenemy -v- Falkirk Council 108759/2011 Mrs Stephanie McTaggart -v- Falkirk Council 108760/2011 Mrs Ann O'Neill -v- Falkirk Council 108761/2011 Mrs Ann O'Neill -v- Falkirk Council 108762/2011 Mrs Susan Ross -v- Falkirk Council 109815/2011 Mrs Vettese Smith -v- Falkirk Council 109816/2011 Mrs Wendy Spalding -v- Falkirk Council 109817/2011 Mrs Kathleen Storrie -v- Falkirk Council 109820/2011 Mr Graham Cowie -v- Falkirk Council 110110/2011 Mrs Maria Paterson -v- Falkirk Council 111057/2010 Mrs Marlyn Baird -v- Falkirk Council 111058/2010 Ms Majory Costa -v- Falkirk Council 111059/2010 Ms Shona Burt -v- Falkirk Council 111060/2010 Ms Lorraine Butler -v- Falkirk Council 111061/2010 Ms Gillian Hunter -v- Falkirk Council 111062/2010 Ms Janet Fish -v- Falkirk Council 111063/2010 Ms Pamela Furby -v- Falkirk Council 111064/2010 Ms Angela Gunn -v- Falkirk Council Printed On: 24-Jan-2020 14:30 By: L Milne Page 4 of 9 111065/2010 Ms Elaine Hoggan -v- Falkirk Council 111067/2010 Ms Anne Lauder -v- Falkirk Council 111068/2010 Ms Helen Liddle -v- Falkirk Council 111069/2010 Ms Shari Anderson -v- Falkirk Council 111070/2010 Ms Elizabeth McAuslan -v- Falkirk Council 111072/2010 Ms Lorraine Moonie -v- Falkirk Council 111073/2010 Ms Catherine Smith -v- Falkirk Council 111074/2010 Ms Sandra Penman -v- Falkirk Council 111075/2010 Ms Carol Ponsonby -v- Falkirk Council 111076/2010 Ms Donna Thomson -v- Falkirk Council 111077/2010 Ms Jane Whyte -v- Falkirk Council 111418/2011 Mrs Margaret Marshall -v- Falkirk Council 111421/2011 Miss Jennifer Shaw -v- Falkirk Council 111422/2011 Mrs Morag Shaw -v- Falkirk Council 111423/2011 Mrs Janice Mould -v- Falkirk Council 111426/2011 Ms Michelle McAllister -v- Falkirk Council 111959/2011 Mrs Eleanor Kirk -v- Falkirk Council 112074/2011 Mrs Susan Meikle -v- Falkirk Council 112271/2011 Miss Susan McArdle -v- Falkirk Council 112273/2011 Mrs Heather Urbanczyk -v- Falkirk Council 112274/2011 Miss Paula Rouse -v- Falkirk Council 112396/2011 Ms Catherine McLean -v- Falkirk Council 112397/2011 Ms Lynn Shirra -v- Falkirk Council 112398/2011 Mrs Margaret Branscombe (Deceased -v- Falkirk Council 112448/2010 Mrs Margaret Somerville -v- Falkirk Council 112451/2010 Mrs Agnes Montgomery -v- Falkirk Council 112452/2010 Ms Aileen Turnbull -v- Falkirk Council 112453/2010 Mrs Alexis Little -v- Falkirk Council 112454/2010 Mrs Alison Cornwall -v- Falkirk Council 112455/2010 Mrs Amanda Hutton -v- Falkirk Council 112456/2010 Mrs Andrea Keenan -v- Falkirk Council 112457/2010 Mrs Angela Kay -v- Falkirk Council 112458/2010 Mrs Angela Reid -v- Falkirk Council 112459/2010 Mrs Ann Fairley -v- Falkirk Council 112460/2010 Mrs Ann Gibson -v- Falkirk Council 112461/2010 Mrs Ann Leask -v- Falkirk Council 112461/2011 Mrs Sandra Campbell -v- Falkirk Council 112462/2010 Mrs Ann Marley -v- Falkirk Council 112462/2011 Mrs Karen Turner -v- Falkirk Council 112463/2010 Mrs Ann Robb -v- Falkirk Council 112464/2010 Mrs Ann Sutherland -v- Falkirk Council 112465/2010 Mrs Anne Allan -v- Falkirk Council Printed On: 24-Jan-2020 14:30 By: L Milne Page 5 of 9 112466/2010 Mrs Anne Hill -v- Falkirk Council 112467/2010 Mrs Anne Matheson -v- Falkirk Council 112468/2010 Mrs Anne Marie Neilson -v- Falkirk Council 112469/2010 Mrs Annie Simpson -v- Falkirk Council 112470/2010 Mrs Carol Muirhead -v- Falkirk Council 112471/2010 Ms Christine Horsburgh -v- Falkirk Council 112473/2010 Miss Christine Moore -v- Falkirk Council 112474/2010 Miss Christine Muir -v- Falkirk Council 112475/2010 Ms Collette Haston -v- Falkirk Council 112476/2010 Miss Debbie Barrie -v- Falkirk Council 112477/2010 Mrs Diane Blair -v- Falkirk Council 112479/2010 Mrs Elaine Millar -v- Falkirk Council 112480/2010 Ms Glenys Talobt -v- Falkirk Council 112481/2010 Mrs Elizabeth Bell -v- Falkirk Council 112482/2010 Mrs Elizabeth Brannan -v- Falkirk Council 112483/2010 Mrs Elizabeth Campbell -v- Falkirk Council 112484/2010 Mrs Elizabeth Liddell -v- Falkirk Council 112485/2010 Mrs Elizabeth McCuish -v- Falkirk Council 112486/2010 Mrs Elizabeth McGookin -v- Falkirk Council 112487/2010 Mrs Elizabeth McGrane -v- Falkirk Council 112489/2010 Mrs Elizabeth O'Donnell -v- Falkirk Council 112491/2010 Mrs Eva Whyte -v- Falkirk Council 112495/2010 Mrs Freida Revena Schieritz -v- Falkirk Council 112496/2010 Mrs Gail McAuslan -v- Falkirk Council 112497/2010 Mrs Grace Black -v- Falkirk Council 112500/2010 Mrs Helen Leadbetter -v- Falkirk Council 112501/2010 Mrs Helen Norwood -v- Falkirk Council 112502/2010 Miss Helen Welsh -v- Falkirk Council 112503/2010 Mrs Issabella Ferguson -v- Falkirk Council 112504/2010 Ms Jacqueline Martin -v- Falkirk Council 112506/2010 Mrs Janet Cumming -v- Falkirk Council 112507/2010 Mrs Janet Kidd -v- Falkirk Council 112508/2010 Mrs Janet Thomson -v- Falkirk Council 112509/2010 Mrs Jean MacLeod -v- Falkirk Council 112511/2010 Mrs Kirsty Middleton -v- Falkirk Council 112512/2010 Mrs Lesley Dawson -v- Falkirk Council 112513/2010 Mrs Lesley Dunn -v- Falkirk Council 112514/2010 Mrs Lilias Burgoyne -v- Falkirk Council 112515/2010 Mrs Linda Mullen -v- Falkirk Council 112516/2010 Mrs Loraine Findlay -v- Falkirk Council 112518/2010 Mrs Lorraine Lynch -v- Falkirk Council 112519/2010 Mrs Lorraine Turnbull -v- Falkirk Council Printed On: 24-Jan-2020 14:30 By: L Milne Page 6 of 9 112521/2010 Mrs Margaret Crossan -v- Falkirk Council 112523/2010 Mrs Margaret Drysdale -v- Falkirk Council 112525/2010 Mrs Margaret Stewart -v- Falkirk Council 112526/2010 Mrs Marion Starr -v- Falkirk Council 112529/2010 Mrs Mary Robertson -v- Falkirk Council 112530/2010 Mrs Mary Templeton -v- Falkirk Council 112532/2010 Mrs Moira Dobbie -v- Falkirk Council 112534/2010 Mrs Norma McCallum -v- Falkirk Council 112536/2010 Mrs Ray Kirkland -v- Falkirk Council 112539/2010 Mrs Robina Meikle -v- Falkirk Council 112540/2010 Mrs Sandra Ballantine -v- Falkirk Council 112542/2010 Mrs Sharon Ainslie -v- Falkirk Council 112543/2010 Mrs Shirley French -v- Falkirk Council 112544/2010 Mrs Shona Graham -v- Falkirk Council 112547/2010 Mrs Susan Wilson -v- Falkirk Council 112548/2010 Mrs Veronica MacKay -v- Falkirk Council 112550/2010 Miss Yvonne Hannah -v- Falkirk Council 112552/2010 Ms Agnes Hardie -v- Falkirk Council 112554/2010 Mrs Mary Craig -v- Falkirk Council 112557/2010 Mrs Agnes Mochrie -v- Falkirk Council 112560/2010 Mrs Caroline Wright -v- Falkirk Council 112561/2010 Mrs Ellen Adams -v- Falkirk Council 112562/2010 Mrs Tracy-Ann Ferguson -v- Falkirk Council 112563/2010 Mrs E Charlotte Downie -v- Falkirk Council 112634/2011 Mrs Carol Brewster -v- Falkirk Council 112736/2011 Miss Annmarie Mcintyre -v- Falkirk Council 112806/2011 Mrs Tracey Ferguson -v- Falkirk Council 112952/2011 Mrs Kathleen Lapping -v- Falkirk Council 112953/2011 Mrs Kathleen Lapping -v- Falkirk Council 113124/2011 Ms Linda Murray -v- Falkirk Council 113318/2011 Mrs Patricia Young -v- Falkirk Council 113386/2011 Mrs Emma Allardyce -v- Falkirk Council 113451/2011 Mrs Heather Shedden -v- Falkirk Council 113841/2010 Mrs Caroline McGrath Dodds -v- Falkirk Council 114545/2010 Ms Patricia Adams -v- Falkirk Council 114546/2010 Ms Alison Dickie -v- Falkirk Council 114549/2010 Mrs Janette Johnstone -v- Falkirk Council 114551/2010 Ms Nicola McIntosh -v- Falkirk Council 114552/2010 Miss Lorraine McMillan -v- Falkirk Council 114554/2010 Mrs Charlene Nimmo -v- Falkirk Council 114556/2010 Mr Eric Roberts -v- Falkirk Council 114558/2010 Mrs Margaret Simpson -v- Falkirk Council Printed On: 24-Jan-2020 14:30 By: L Milne Page 7 of 9 114559/2010 Mrs Agnes Stirling -v- Falkirk Council 114560/2010 Mrs Linda Ure -v- Falkirk Council 114748/2011 Ms Elaine MacDonald -v- Falkirk Council 115161/2011 Mrs Joanne Bennie -v- Falkirk Council 115316/2011 Mrs Rhona McGuire -v- Falkirk Council 115366/2011 Mrs Linda Fortheringham -v- Falkirk Council 115499/2011 Ms Dawn Millar -v- Falkirk Council 115542/2011 Mrs Catherine Ritchie -v- Falkirk Council 115918/2011 Miss Alison Gibson -v- Falkirk Council 116313/2011 Mrs Leslie Ritchie -v- Falkirk Council 116314/2011 Mrs Yvonne Frame -v- Falkirk Council 116316/2011 Miss Cecilla Jenner -v- Falkirk Council 116317/2011 Mrs Eleanor Brown -v- Falkirk Council 116359/2011 Mrs Elra Walls -v- Falkirk Council 116406/2011 Mrs Patricia Logue -v- Falkirk Council 116569/2010 Mrs Margaret Hunter -v- Falkirk Council 116570/2010 Mrs Irene Henderson -v- Falkirk Council 116715/2011 Ms Rhona Smith -v- Falkirk Council 117416/2010 Mrs Marion Cassidy -v- Falkirk Council 117417/2010 Ms Linda Deans -v- Falkirk Council 117418/2010 Ms Anne Douglas -v- Falkirk Council 117420/2010 Ms Eleanor McCulloch -v- Falkirk Council 117421/2010 Ms Moira McLean -v- Falkirk Council 117422/2010 Ms Alison Moyes -v- Falkirk Council 4100127/2013 Mrs Margaret Pringle -v- Falkirk Council 4100219/2012 Mrs Elizabeth Murray -v- Falkirk Council 4100220/2012 Mrs Sandra McEwan -v- Falkirk Council 4100222/2012 Mrs Irene Campbell -v- Falkirk Council 4100478/2012 Mrs Claire Thomson -v- Falkirk Council 4100502/2012 Mrs Stephanie McTaggart -v- Falkirk Council 4100763/2012 Mrs Clare Wood -v- Falkirk Council 4101228/2012 Mrs Suzanne Helen Brown -v- Falkirk Council 4101697/2012 Mrs Sylvia McFarlane -v- Falkirk Council 4102222/2017 Mrs Agnes Lattka -v- Falkirk Council 4102234/2013 Miss Tracey Ann Clark -v- Falkirk Council 4102237/2017 Mrs Catherine Carmichael -v- Falkirk Council 4102869/2012 Mrs Cathy Knox -v- Falkirk Council 4103058/2012 Mrs Carol Crawford -v- Falkirk Council 4103059/2012 Mrs Janice Wilson -v- Falkirk Council 4103060/2012 Mrs Janice Wilson -v- Falkirk Council 4103061/2012 Mrs Anne Strang -v- Falkirk Council 4103062/2012 Mrs Anne Strang -v- Falkirk Council Printed On: 24-Jan-2020 14:30 By: L Milne Page 8 of 9 4103269/2012 Ms Margaret Crothers -v- Falkirk Council 4103459/2012 Mrs Rose Linda Kemp -v- Falkirk Council 4104698/2012 Mr Alan Graham -v- Falkirk Council 4104699/2012 Mr James Sharp -v- Falkirk Council 4104700/2012 Mrs Helen Sharp -v- Falkirk Council 4104949/2012 Mrs Carol Stewart -v- Falkirk Council 4104950/2012 Miss Janis Pepper -v- Falkirk Council 4104951/2012 Mrs Lynn Hunter -v- Falkirk Council 4104952/2012 Mrs Helen Benei -v- Falkirk Council 4106869/2013 Mr Richard Murray -v- Falkirk Council 4110769/2012 Mrs Linda McCormick -v- Falkirk Council